What always amazes me about capitalism is how it often manages to allocate resources efficiently. Nobody is raising large cattle herds down in farm country. Land that can be farmed is generally farmed, because that provides the best return. Land that can't be farmed, is ranched. This idea that you have to give up farming to have meat doesn't take this into account.
You and Malthus like to extrapolate, but extrapolation is rarely a smart idea, unless you're trying to scare people.
Just like there will never be a day when we go from having oil to not having oil, the same will occur with meat. As the demand for a commodity outpaces supply, the price will rise. Some people will find ways to use less of the commodity, some people will find ways to replace the commodity, and some people will find ways to increase the supply of the commodity, now that the higher price allows more expensive methods to be profitably used.
Partly they didn't, they hunted the animal. Or the animal provided other stuff - milk, eggs, leather, bones. People need a source of protien that contains all the amino acids they need and for earlier societies meat is an easy way robust way to get that.
And earlier societies were not great anout effificent ise of land and animals. The near extinction of the Amercan bison is one examples.
And if you can't till the land efficiently, sheep and cattle are a very efficient use of it. If you can, having pigs and chickens eat the plant waste is also very efficient.
Furthermore it is completely pointless to compare economics of ancient cultures with a modern industrialized civilization.
Try moving 500 bushels of stuff a quarter mile with a tractor, and without it.
We are tapped out. If the rest of the planet starts eating meat at the rate that the first world does (~150 kg of beef per person per year), we'll need another planet to feed them. There is literally not enough land to do it on.
I recommend this XKCD for an idea of the scale to which we've appropriated Earth for raising our livestock:
And this UN FAO report, "Livestock's long shadow", on how much of Earth we've actually used for raising livestock, and the devastating environmental consequences:
http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.htm
edit: adding this figure from the report about land usage just so you understand the situation clearly:
Where the hell did you get this number from? I buy all my beef from a farmer who's a friend of a friend. A year's supply is purchased all at once, so I have a pretty good idea of how much of it we eat. My family of four goes through less than 250 lbs (about 110kg) of beef in a year, yet your statistic is that we should be eating roughly half a ton of it per year?
If you're going to make shit up, at least make it sound reasonable.
Green Revolution agriculture would be destructive even if it were 100% vegetarian.
Historically, your argument is correct, but you're inferring that meat is efficient in the present, when it plainly is not. The planet is resource-strapped, and meat consumption is the main reason. And this is without a majority of earth eating a meat-heavy diet.
The human population has more than doubled since the 1960s. This is due to a massive increase in food supply. Increased meat consumption is a side effect of this luxury. The root problems, to address your concerns, are not meat - they're pump-driven irrigation, diesel-powered tractors, nitrogen fertilizers, chemical pesticides and herbicides, and all the other things that have both increased the arable land supply and increased the productivity of that arable land.
How did you get that number?
>>but you're inferring that meat is efficient in the present
Apart from the first world countries, agriculture productivity in most poor and developing countries is still at where it was middle ages. In my own country(India) there are farmers that still plough the land with cattle, the remaining grain processing methods are super outdated. These sort of stone age farming practices, combined with stagnant government policies making it difficult for importing agriculture equipment, add to this no coherent thought or depth in making long term investments in irrigation infrastructure is what makes this whole process inefficient. Not Meat.
>>The planet is resource-strapped
The planet has plenty of resources we just need to know how to tap into them efficiently.
This is an empty phrase. Where is the arable land? Where is the pasture land? How are you going to raise meat in the future when there is nowhere left to raise it?
Part of this "efficiency" is to stop taking grain/roughage and running it through an animal's metabolism in order to produce protein for human consumption. There are better ways, like http://impossiblefoods.com/.
As for "Impossible Foods", I don't understand the fixation on making fake meat and dairy products. To me, that's just encouraging the shift away from natural and minimally processed foods, toward a junk food diet of things manufactured in factories from raw resources of industrial agriculture - monocropped fields of soy and corn farmed with industrial poisons and lab engineering.
Factory junk food is our diet problem, not meat. It's also our environmental destruction problem.
Animals are a way of turning inedible things into edible things. Grass? Well, you could till it all, or just turn sheep and cattle loose on it. Grain hulls? Throw them away, or feed them to the chickens. Spoiled garbage? Pigs will eat it. For as long as we've farmed, animals have increased rather than decreased the food supply.