News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jaron Lanier: "Long Live Closed-Source Software!" by bitwize on Tuesday January 01, 2008 @06:23AM (#94099)
If you look at the software that people actually use to do things -- compose music, design an airplane, edit a video, design a logo, lay out a brochure, etc., virtually anything besides computer programming -- the best-of-breed tools are proprietary and exist only on proprietary platforms (typically Windows or Mac).

This is because to just about everybody except computer programmers, the interface is the application, and considerable time and money have been invested in things which are more important than beautiful code -- things like usability, "looking pretty", and functioning in a way that mirrors how the intended audience things. This is something that programmers are notoriously poor at; for example programmers-who-are-also-musicians are likely to come up with music tools that make sense to them but utterly baffle nonprogrammer musicians. (Think Csound, Rosegarden, etc.)

Things like AutoCAD are innovative not because they contain fancy new algorithms but because they enable large chunks of the population to do things that they couldn't do before. And AutoCAD is proprietary, expensive, and runs only on Microsoft Windows.

In short, it's looking more and more like proprietary software is what has brought us real freedom.

There are no comments on this comment yet.