Re:Is This Justice? Charging an Eighth Grader with a Felony ...
by pyre on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:25PM
(#9409538)
> By your reasoning, picking a lock or guessing a combination couldn't be breaking in because you didn't literally break anything.
What reasoning? I said that "breaking and entering" can happen through an open window. My point was to modify the analogy so that the act of breaking & entering was "easy" and non-destructive bringing it closer to the level of severity in the situation that we are discussing.
Gaining access to someone's password has a much lower bar than something like picking a lock which requires a certain set of skills, and may imply a certain level of intent. The student didn't hookup a laptop to the school network and run metasploit.
Re:Is This Justice? Charging an Eighth Grader with a Felony ...
by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:43PM
(#9409262)
Actually the definition includes "with criminal intent". Without that, there's no crime.
Re:Is This Justice? Charging an Eighth Grader with a Felony ...
by kazinator on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:58PM
(#9409378)
That aspect seems to be state-dependent in the US, according to:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breaking_and_Entering#United_St...
In New York, the intent is not required. However, ironically with regard to this case, it is that way in Florida.
Re:Is This Justice? Charging an Eighth Grader with a Felony ...
by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:21PM
(#9410633)
Hm. I followed that link, and didn't read anything about intent not being required. What did I miss?
The offense is an abstraction that doesn't require physically damaging any security mechanism.
By your reasoning, picking a lock or guessing a combination couldn't be breaking in because you didn't literally break anything.