News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by parfe on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:40PM (#9406050)
Very brave of Ken to call out women, black people, and the LGBT community.

Safe spaces don't insulate minority groups from ideas they don't like. Those groups are exposed to ideas they don't like all the time, every day, via every avenue of media.

A safe space is a moment of solace to discuss issues specific groups are particularly affected by without being berated by the 18 year old generic white male libertarian who seems so keen on letting the minority groups how they should be behaving.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by formulaT on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:10AM (#9406141)
I see things the other way around. The generic white males are constantly berated and ridiculed in the mainstream media. People are constantly getting in trouble or losing their jobs for saying the wrong thing, e.g. Satya Nadella for not knowing the "right" response to the issue of women not asking for raises.
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tomlock on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:41AM (#9406217)
I chuckled a little because you mention "generic white males" and then Satya in the next sentence.

Satya's comments were poorly stated and he said as much. People spoke freely about it, and he clarified. Free speech in action!

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by formulaT on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:48AM (#9406236)
You must be easily amused then. Satya Nadella was an example of people in generally being required to speak in a politically correct way. Haven't you heard of intersectionality? Nadella could still be accused of having male privilege in spite of being non-White.

And your analysis is very shallow. Of course speech was "free" in the legal sense, that is not the issue. The issue is that even though his honest opinion was that in the long run, women's approach might not be a big disadvantage, he was forced to recant and give the "right" answer.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tomlock on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:10AM (#9406286)
I am easily amused and I also know what intersectionality is.

I'm interested in why you have the perspective that Satya was being honest and then recanted, since he pretty clearly stated that he misspoke, and it is easy to see how he misspoke. My perspective is he was speaking in terms of how tech ought to be for women, but failed to mention that the situation for women was currently different. The idea that women ought to be able to trust the system is a given, but Satya didn't say "but it currently isn't so" and in his apology he cleared that up. Good on him!

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by formulaT on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:36AM (#9406475)
My perspective is he was speaking in terms of how tech ought to be for women, but failed to mention that the situation for women was currently different.

That's just completely wrong, watch the video again. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ndm_RSvAgO4

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tomlock on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:03AM (#9406542)
I disagree. Could you help me understand why you think he backed down rather than just clarifying his comments?
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by formulaT on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:48AM (#9406654)
If you watch the video, there is nothing that suggests Satya is not talking about the way things are in the workplace, not they way they should be. I just don't see where you are getting this idea from. Do you have a single source for this?
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by yummyfajitas on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:52AM (#9406245)
Its not an uncommon use of "white male". Most of the media describes Asians in tech as white - it is the only way to preserve the narrative.
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by DanBC on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:46AM (#9406502)
> Most of the media describes Asians in tech as white

Do you have any examples?

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by yummyfajitas on Monday April 20, 2015 @07:08AM (#9407236)
For example, "Google Admits it Hires Too Many White Dudes" or "Amazon’s Diversity Report Is Another White-Male-Dominated Tech Story".

http://techcrunch.com/2014/05/28/google-admits-it-hires-too-...

http://techcrunch.com/2014/11/03/amazon-diversity-2014/

(Both reports show that Asians are overrepresented, white people represented, and others underrepresented.)

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by DanBC on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:13PM (#9410587)
You said "Most of the media describes Asians in tech as white - it is the only way to preserve the narrative."

Neither of those articles - from a single source - describe Asians as white; Asian is explicitly broken out as a seperate category and described as a minority.

"It’s no better on the race front, either, with the highest minority being Asian at 34% in tech and next to non-existent in anything else."

Did you miss the fact that Asians are only "overrepresented" in tech, and not in other parts of Google?

Amazon doesn't break the job types into tech and non tech. They do Amazon everything and Amazon management. But even that tech crunch report shows that they have seperated out white, Asian, black, hispanic, and other.

These are weak examples considering the claim you made.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by detcader on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:55AM (#9406251)
Women are photoshopped and presented as objects in the mainstream media. Women are constantly getting in trouble or losing their jobs for saying the wrong thing, e.g. "no" to sex and harassment.
Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:42PM (#9406056)
>Safe spaces don't insulate minority groups from ideas they don't like. Those groups are exposed to ideas they don't like all the time, every day, via every avenue of media.

It seems you and I live in a different country.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by bandrami on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:41AM (#9406216)
> It seems you and I live in a different country.

Well, the discussion here is about the US, where that is definitely true. "Safe spaces" give straight white men the slightest taste of what the rest of the world is like for people who aren't that trifecta. And, predictably, we straight white men freak the hell out when exposed to that...

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by candu on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:07AM (#9406280)
Personally, I've always been skeptical of the "straight white men" trope.

Yes, each of these specifiers confer a statistical advantage, but this is such a large demographic group (even within the US) that it seems bizarre to treat it as homogenous in any way.

(Then again, perhaps I'm just allergic to marketing-speak, and prefer to think of people as such.)

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:11AM (#9406432)
>Well, the discussion here is about the US, where that is definitely true.

No it isn't. Not only is the media apparatus in full-throated support of "women, black people, and the LGBT community", the last people on the planet who should need safe spaces are the people who demand them: wealthy and the UMC white women at places like Vassar and Oberlin.

Truly disadvantaged people can't afford to be that weak.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:22AM (#9406588)
I'm not interested in diving into what you mean by "full-throated support," but would instead like to ask, why shouldn't they? Why are those groups of people not worthy of support, full-throated or otherwise?

If those groups are now working to obtain more economic and political power, in a world that has historically and remains economically and politically skewed against them, why would anyone not support that?

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:05AM (#9406716)
>I'm not interested in diving into what you mean by "full-throated support," but would instead like to ask, why shouldn't they? Why are those groups of people not worthy of support, full-throated or otherwise?

I didn't say they shouldn't. I was merely pointing out these groups get no more in the way of negative messaging from the media than white men. Quite a bit less, actually.

>If those groups are now working to obtain more economic and political power, in a world that has historically and remains economically and politically skewed against them, why would anyone not support that?

Why indeed? Maybe because they already have political power in proportion to their size? More so, in fact - if you want to know who's in charge all you need to do is find out who you can't criticize. White men, at what, about 30% of the US population, seem to be quite safe to criticize, wouldn't you say?

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:17AM (#9406748)
What? They already have political power in proportion to their size?

How do you figure that? There are 19 women heads of state in the world right now, out of 190-some countries. Worldwide, only about 22% of parliamentarians (MPs, representatives, etc) are women. I'm pretty sure women make up more than 22% of the population.

There's also a never-ending raft of laws, especially in the US, aimed at controlling women's access to health care--women, not men, are having female-specific health care decisions made for them by (male-dominated) force of law, rather than by consultation with a doctor or personal agency.

As for all this talk about who gets criticized, you make it sound like white men have, in addition to political dominance, unimaginably thin skin and sensitive constitutions. "Stop! We're being criticized! They're saying we have all the powerrrrr!" My eyes, they can't stop rolling.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:52AM (#9406842)
>How do you figure that? There are 19 women heads of state in the world right now, out of 190-some countries. Worldwide, only about 22% of parliamentarians (MPs, representatives, etc) are women. I'm pretty sure women make up more than 22% of the population.

We were talking about the US. I have little interest in what other countries do unless it becomes a problem for mine.

>There's also a never-ending raft of laws, especially in the US, aimed at controlling women's access to health care...

If by that you mean adding restrictions to infanticide, well, I suppose they get proposed on a regular basis. They hardly ever pass, though, and when they do they're gutted by the courts. Not what I'd describe as a "never-ending raft". More like a soggy paper boat.

>As for all this talk about who gets criticized, you make it sound like white men have, in addition to political dominance, unimaginably thin skin and sensitive constitutions.

Nice try. Just because I draw your attention to a double standard doesn't mean I'm ready to run to a "safe space". I'm simply pointing out white men, at 30% of the population, don't control the country.

If men actually had "political dominance" we'd have laws against paternity fraud. And you wouldn't be able to sponge off your ex after deciding you weren't that into him any more. Women pay less than half the health care dollars and yet they use 2/3 of the services. That hardly seems fair, does it?

But no. More than half the voters are women complaining about having no power while at the same time calling the shots.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Monday April 20, 2015 @11:47AM (#9408865)
Political representation by women in the US is no better than the rest of the world.

White men, at 30%, do control the country. You are misinformed if you think otherwise.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:19PM (#9410228)
Then why is paternity fraud legal? Where I live a woman's husband is on the hook for her child if it was conceived while they were married. Even if it isn't his and/or they divorce before the baby is born. Does that seem reasonable to you? Is that what you'd expect if your imaginary patriarchy was real?

Why do women and minorities get special consideration in employment and education? Why don't women pay their own freight on health care?

I've present support for my argument and you've... well, you've re-presented your assertion.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:18PM (#9410613)
In a very real, observable sense--political representation--white men far outweigh their population size, and outweigh every other group put together.

To go from that actual real fact about the world, to the conclusion that women therefore rule the world, takes a rather grand leap of imagination.

(I also can't figure out why you have that fixation on family law, but it doesn't support the assertion that women rule the world, and it doesn't really make any sense on its own.)

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Monday April 20, 2015 @10:41PM (#9411996)
>In a very real, observable sense--political representation--white men far outweigh their population size, and outweigh every other group put together.

You keep saying that, but proof by assertion isn't going to get you very far.

>To go from that actual real fact about the world, to the conclusion that women therefore rule the world, takes a rather grand leap of imagination.

Again, we were talking about the US. Please try to stay on topic.

>I also can't figure out why you have that fixation on family law...

Because it's grossly unfair to men, and it wouldn't be if men actually exercised the power you imagine.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Monday April 20, 2015 @10:51PM (#9412023)
What?

You seriously don't know the gender/race make-up of our elected officials?

Is that what your hang-up is? You really think there are more women and people of color in office and in positions of power than white men?

Really?

If you are that misinformed, I am a little astonished.

Just look it up.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @04:04AM (#9412750)
>You seriously don't know the gender/race make-up of our elected officials?

Of course I know what it is. I also know it's irrelevant, since women make up the majority of voters. Politicians don't get elected if they don't pander to women.

You clearly don't understand how power is wielded in a democracy, which is probably how you arrived at views so at odds with reality.

Again, forget about the skin color and sex of people in office. It doesn't matter. Look at the laws, and look at the way they are executed by the courts.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by Frondo on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @11:52AM (#9414890)
So you're looking at the composition of people in power, and you're saying "those people, the ones in power, DON'T have power".

I guess once you start denying objective reality and common sense, you can go anywhere, including "women secretly rule the world". Well done.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by tsotha on Saturday April 25, 2015 @01:00AM (#9437272)
I guess if you don't the way democracies work you could get the impression people in legislatures are just doing whatever they want.

I guess looking at outcomes is too complicated. That's okay. Men will just do what we always do - roll our eyes at your complaints and shoulder most of the load.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by aptwebapps on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:51PM (#9406088)
> Very brave of Ken to call out women, black people, and the LGBT community.

He didn't do that.

He used the term 'safe spaces' to talk about something else, which was obviously a mistake but please don't get hung up on the terminology and read the whole and follow a few of the links.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by parfe on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:54PM (#9406093)
>He didn't do that.

You must have read his writing differently than I considering he wrote:

>I call these young people out for valuing illusory and subjective safety over liberty.

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by aptwebapps on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:03AM (#9406126)
I can see how that sounds but take a look a the preceding paragraph and the links in it:

"For some time I've been mean [0] to university students who feel entitled to a "safe space" [1] — by which they seem to mean a space where they are insulated [2] from ideas they don't like [3]."

He does not mean "I hereby call out out these young people ..." but rather "This is what I did in the preceding links". This is a sticky topic and it's really easy to read stuff into things that isn't there - especially when the author expropriates a term like 'safe spaces' but if you read it critically and follow a few of the links I think you'll discover that he is in no way attacking minorities.

0. http://popehat.com/2014/11/05/breaking-existence-of-u-of-ore... 1. http://popehat.com/2015/04/14/fear-and-butthurt-at-uc-san-di... 2. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/22/opinion/sunday/judith-shul... 3. http://www.dailytarheel.com/article/2015/04/opinion-campus-s...

Re:“Safe Spaces” and the Mote in America's Eye by theVirginian on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:58PM (#9406104)
This isn't tumblr...