News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by tomsaffell on Friday November 13, 2009 @01:55PM (#940523)
Totally agree that she was not right for the job, but the process was a bit nightmare-ish :

  “That’s all.  Good luck with your job search.”  The phone clicked-- I was stunned.
In my previous job I conducted a lot of interviews of an analytical style. Some people bombed so badly that is was clear well before the end that they wouldn't make the next round. In those cases, I used the remaining time to either talk to them about the career hopes/goals, or to explain how they could have better approached the problem (these skills are partly learnt..) to help prepare them for their next interview. The way I saw it was that they were expecting 30 mins of my time, so they would get it, even if they weren't up to the job. It a courtesy, and it's also self interest - burnt interviewees make a lot of noise on campus.

When I was 'senior' I never applied to McKinsey, because I'd heard so many horror stories about their interviews - I just didn't want to go anywhere near them. I landed a job with one of their main competitors and spent 5 happy years there...

Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by uuilly on Friday November 13, 2009 @02:31PM (#940590)
I totally agree. A company gains nothing by being dismissive. I've interviewed at about 20 companies in the last 10 years, not to mention VC / Angel pitches. Only Google left a foul taste in my mouth. As a CS guy I've had dozens of analytical interviews and have largely done well with them. But the guy who interviewed me from Google acted as if he was doing me a favor. He was curt from the first moment and would sigh and groan if I asked for more specifics on a question. He too basically hung up on me.
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by jongraehl on Friday November 13, 2009 @05:41PM (#940993)
He sounds like a jerk, but imagine how much it boosts his morale to feel so superior (even if unfairly so).
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by ashishbharthi on Friday November 13, 2009 @02:13PM (#940556)
Googlers are not that bad at ending interviews either. I think this was just one perticular person (Anna) thing.
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by mbrubeck on Friday November 13, 2009 @03:53PM (#940791)
Agreed. I was rejected from Google after an on-site interview, but they were quite polite and professional about it.
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by diN0bot on Friday November 13, 2009 @03:06PM (#940680)
i agree. i interviewed at Google and thought the whole process was lots of fun. i didn't have any complaints about the people. (i might be biased because i was offered a job; however, i didn't take it, preferring to work at a startup instead.)
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by ig1 on Friday November 13, 2009 @04:38PM (#940866)
That's debatable. Many candidates would rather just end a failed interview early and do something they'd like with their time.
Re:My Nightmare Interviews With Google by ggrot on Saturday November 14, 2009 @12:36AM (#941463)
Maybe, but I can't imagine they would be very upset by the interviewer continuing to take a little more of their time either. At the very least, it gives you the feeling that the interviewer fairly assessed you instead of dismissing you because of one flummoxed question. When I interview someone who quickly seems unlikely to pass an intervew, I try to use as much time as possible to make sure my initial impression was correct and the candidate just didn't get unlucky and/or just happens to be overly nervous. Some people are great employees but are bad at being interviewed.