News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French Senate Backs Bid To Force Google To Disclose Searc... by JoshTriplett on Saturday April 18, 2015 @04:42PM (#9400940)
There's a difference between clicking a link (where "open in default browser" is the obvious behavior, and there's no advantage to forcing any particular browser) and searching for an address (where it makes sense to recognize an address and offer special handling, such as displaying a map, or directions).

Searching for an address is a special case of search. If you search for an address, you're unlikely to get useful results by just searching the web, unless the address happens to be that of a business who lists their address on their site; even then, the result you want from the address is probably a map or directions, rather than the site for the business at that address. So what, precisely, would you suggest Google or another search engine do in that case to continue providing a good user experience? (Answers such as "don't do that" are obviously wrong, as are answers like "go to extra trouble to build a generic search plugin API and make users explicitly select a map provider". Neither of those provides a satisfactory experience for users.)

Re:French Senate Backs Bid To Force Google To Disclose Searc... by mercurial on Saturday April 18, 2015 @05:10PM (#9401059)
> There's a difference between clicking a link (where "open in default browser" is the obvious behavior, and there's no advantage to forcing any particular browser) and searching for an address (where it makes sense to recognize an address and offer special handling, such as displaying a map, or directions).

Clearly, there is a competitive advantage in controlling the browser, or Google would not have spend so much money in giant billboards in the Paris subway to explain how Chrome was better than anything.

> So what, precisely, would you suggest Google or another search engine do in that case to continue providing a good user experience?

Agree with map service vendors on a standard API, and make it possible in the settings to select the service to handle an address search. You know, competition and all that.