Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by Hytosys on Saturday April 18, 2015 @05:43AM
(#9398844)
I'll ask this with the obvious risk of making a correlation: would you have the same opinion of kkkautoblocker — a tool that blocked anyone who associated with the leaders of a hate group?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by ryanlol on Saturday April 18, 2015 @06:24AM
(#9398906)
Depends entirely on the contents of those peoples tweets. What if one of those leaders of a hate group was also a linux kernel developer and regularly made interesting technical tweets?
Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by Hytosys on Saturday April 18, 2015 @06:31AM
(#9398921)
I alluded to this dilemma in my original post: "I accept any incidental losses." This choice of course only applies to the case where people use block lists themselves, not where social networks ban people.
My suggestion is that social networks ban users wherein harassment is strictly obvious, not wherein a prejudice opinion is even only implied. This is a tricky judgement call that the article tries to dissect, and unfortunately to which I clearly have little to contribute.
Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by ryanlol on Saturday April 18, 2015 @11:57AM
(#9399853)
Well then, my opinion on kkkautoblocker would be no different than my opinion on ggautoblocker. They're both stupid non-solutions, anyone who's actually trying to harass people will be able to circumvent them...
People should also consider that if they can't handle the vile cesspit that the internet is, using it is optional.
Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by tsotha on Saturday April 18, 2015 @01:52PM
(#9400343)
Yes, I would, though we both know that's a spurious comparison. For one thing, since you don't control the block list, and you don't know the people who control the list personally, you have no idea who they're blocking. Could be people who have nothing to do with the KKK.
For another... if people you don't know are being malicious to you maybe you should step back and think about your public face. People who draw a lot of trolls do so for a reason.
Re:'Troll hunting' algorithm could make web a better place
by NotableAlamode on Saturday April 18, 2015 @06:18AM
(#9398896)
Why do you draw a false analogy between a racist group and a distributed online movement that has been extremely successful at exposing corruption in games journalism?