..using the completely contrived (and incorrect) definition of "feminism" that asserts anyone who believes in equality is a feminist.
That is not how groups work.
I believe that black people should have the same rights as everyone else too, but that does not make me a member of the "black power" movement. I believe in meditation and stilling of the mind, but that does not make me a Buddhist.
Why is feminism the only group that tries to claim dominion over otherwise unaffiliated people? As far as I know, it is unique in that respect. I can't think of any other ideology, good or bad, that operates in this way.
Given the behavior of prominent/famous feminists (say, campaigning for the abolition of due process, which is the single most fucked up thing I think I've read this year), that is not a label I want to be anywhere near. It is anti-intellectual, it is toxic, and I want nothing to do with it.
Seriously, you did it, to me, in your original post.
Why is that? What is the authoritative definition you use that allows you to presume other people's ideologies in such a way?
Unfortunately, once again, you kind of didn't directly answer what I asked you. I'm starting to sense a pattern here.
Let's try this again:
What is the authoritative definition you use that allows you to presume other people's ideologies in such a way?
As previously mentioned, I do not wish to be associated with feminism in any sense, broad or otherwise, because of its ever increasing association with (ir|a)rationality and toxicity. I prefer to be called a humanist, or an egalitarian, because I believe in equality for all, not just for a particular sex.
With that in mind, I'm asking you to define, preferably from a dispassionate and neutral source, how you can claim that label applies to someone. From what I can see, the "if you believe in women's rights, you are a feminist" definition is circular and held primarily by self-described feminists. If you have any evidence to the contrary, I would love to see it.
Regardless of whether you did this intentionally or whether you just naively spouted this, it's a really shitty tactic to employ when conversing with people.
the advocacy of women's rights on the grounds of political, social, and economic equality to men.
synonyms: the women's movement, the feminist movement, women's liberation, female emancipation, women's rights; informalwomen's lib
"a longtime advocate of feminism"Its not. Lots of groups movement groups claim that most everyone believes whatever their key belief is, its a standard rhetorical strategy to leverage the common desire to fit in.
>If you said yes to any of these questions, you're a feminist.
There's danger in treating ideological positions in the same way we treat party affiliations. The idea of the "motte and bailey doctrine" [0] is relevant here, where ideas like "feminism is just the belief that women are people!" are the motte, and more controversial ideas are the bailey that not only do many adherents support, but then use the near-universal acceptance of the motte as reasoning why people should accept the package deal of including the bailey as well.
[0] http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-bric...
Isn't it amazing that this is a thing, and you're certainly not alone in feeling this way, and yet people can still support the movement that has you feeling this way?
On my few social media accounts, which are linked to me as a person, I'm more than happy to criticize the government(s), I'm more than happy to criticize the NSA, GCHQ, etc, I'm more than happy to criticize politicians and many other things but I'm sure as hell never going to voice my opinion on modern feminism/the social justice movement on these accounts.
This is a logical fallacy (Association). If you believe in X, then you are Y. You can believe in all of those listed criteria and not consider yourself a feminist, because it is a broad topic and some viewpoints are more extreme then others.
It's not about self-description, though. At all.
Reality is objective. Get over it.
As for my actual point: "Doing X makes you Y" is about public perception, not self-perception. If you conflate the two, you do more damage to yourself than anything I could ever say.
> about: classicsnoot.tumblr.com
Oh.
We saw that happen to a hackernews poster a few years ago.
College campuses are capitulating to these people's demands.
I think this movement will let off some steam and people will stop taking it seriously, but I don't think it is unfair to worry that they will take real positions of power in the future.
They're very highly active, and in control of, many student unions throughout say the US and UK. Student union reps often go on to become politicians, so it is indeed something worth worrying about.
Especially since their movement is based on dividing people and making one group the oppressor and the other the victim, even if such perceived oppression has no basis in reality.
Their movement has entirely turned against gay men now and blasts them as being "oppressive". They're almost as bad about FTM transsexuals. There's really no telling where it goes next. Most bizarrely though is the vast majority of the division is being carried out by largely straight, white, middle class or higher women at the helm.
I don't see how someone like that would actually win office. Too insane.
> Yeah, there's a handful of misguided activists who read
> malice into everything. But they're the minority
> (albeit a loud one).
And there's the problem. It's not that the represent them majority, it's that, by sheer volume, they've managed to set the terms of the the debate to suit their own viewpoint, biases, and beliefs. Even movement has its fruitcakes and its lunatics, but when they're the ones setting the agenda, it becomes a real problem and actively undermines the otherwise noble, sensible aims.But isn't the problem the fact that if nobody speaks out against them that they'll eventually continue to grow? I mean, a minority opinion graduating into the opinion of a majority isn't exactly improbable or unprecedented.
And if that doesn't happen, you'll possibly have something even worse; you'll end up with what's been going on with Muslims where people think all muslims are extremist terrorists who hold radical views (because of a minority). Obviously that's not the case but many people really do think like that. Not helping matters is their most prominent leaders remain silent on those extremist views. Sure, you'll have a few leaders here and there putting in PR time while speaking out against extremism, but there's no conviction and it's not backed up by actual actions. The moderates and their leaders should be the fiercest fighters of that extremism and that's just simply not the case.
No. Tumblr-style "social justice activists" (scare-quotes because Tumblr activists have comparatively little to do with serious professional activism) are insane, unpersuasive, and prone to triggering strong backlashes against their own views.
The issue is that a very small but loud group of online activists are becoming able to have disproportionate influence. It's easy for online mobs to form on sites like Twitter or Tumblr, which have messaging systems that promote reblogging/retweeting/"signal boosting" and are neither good for nuanced discussion nor corrections. Companies and organizations depend so heavily on Internet social media for their PR that they quickly bow to mob pressure in terms of self-censorship or firing "problematic" employees.
So it's not so much that the "social justice activists" will spread in terms of population, it's that they can have a chilling effect where the other side doesn't speak out, out of fear of the nuclear option of online shaming being used against them. This can lead to one side dominating the conversation despite being unpersuasive.
There is no conversation. They don't converse with those holding conflicting opinions. In fact, with Twitter, they've built out the BlockBot to automatically censor all and any deemed to have dissented against the narrative.
When you've a movement that is based on very flawed statistics and that places emphasis on hypersensitive feelings over reality, dissent containing reality or fact is a threat. It's far easier to censor the dissent than to engage it.
"Your right to swing your fist ends where my nose begins" is a good analogy, I think.
Tumblr, as an example, is not a place where you can admit moderate views about feminism or identity politics without getting shouted down. This results in moderates self-censoring and refusing to talk about their views publicly online, resulting in a hateful echo chamber completely lacking in subtlety.
As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of decrying someone's argument due to race or gender approaches 1.
Really, this is just a precursor for Godwin's Law, because this will be inevitably followed by the argument that Hitler or the Nazis also utilized zealous discrimination.
If I had to guess I would attribute it to the fact that the internet allows radical viewpoints to not only be heard more easily, but it also enables congregation point to exist. I'm not implying that this type of radicalism is new millennial-exclusive thinking, just that it's more noticeable now.
I have experienced this from those older than millenials, too. But as someone in their mid-20s, I’m kind of in the thick of the part of the internet where the bullies reside, and it’s certainly not just on Tumblr.
Nope, egalitarian here. I actively choose not to use the term "feminism" because the only encounters I've had with "feminists" have shown that they aren't accepting of anyone who disagrees with them in the slightest. (yes now tell me I need to "get out more", I have.)
Not only that, but in my experience with feminism, to not be a feminist is to be a racist (according to them), and that's kind of how you sound.
There are good people who believe in equality that don't want to wear the moniker of feminism, believe it or don't.
You come up to buy some lemonade.
I ask you "Do you like lemonade?"
You reply yes.
I take a cup of lemonade and put a handful of dirt in it. I offer it to you. You refuse it, because you don't like the taste of dirt.
Is it fair for me to challenge your original claim of liking lemonade? Likewise, if you maintain that you do in fact enjoy lemonade, are we just quibbling over semantics? Or is there a substantive reason why you refused to drink it?
That's what the GP is claiming. When dealing with "feminists", he senses toxic and anti-intellectual attitudes. That's a substantive claim, not a semantic one.