>> Why should he use a new thing?
But this is not actually the same question as the reputation assignment. It's quite possible that the consumer could decide that there was NO positive reason to use Bitcoin without having made the negative reputation assignments that have become common now. I'm not trying to make the case that there are sufficient positive reasons to use it - just that the reasons to not use it aren't rationally assigned.
I agree that many of the reasons people stay away aren't rational. However I don't think all are irrational -
Someone might compromise my computer or my wallet provider and get all the money. This has happened repeatedly. There may be nothing I can do about that, technically or legally. While this is a bit like Madoff, I don't have to interact with Madoff to obtain or use dollars.
To obtain and use BTC I pretty much have to take the risk of dealing with the BTC community.
What's irrational about not wanting to store your personal wealth in a currency where the value fluctuates constantly, many times by multiple percentages points in a single day?
If you don't keep a wallet with some BTC in it, then what good is it? If you're just using it as a means to transfer dollars around, you're definitely in a niche market -- and it could be argued that the rational one is the guy staying the hell away from BTC.
I don't think this is as powerful as you do. Particularly when coupled with the fact that Joe Average uses American Dollars every single day, and has done for his whole life. Trust is conditioned in, it's implicit at that point.
Why should he use a new thing? Especially with all the dodgy stuff he sees around it?
>>So the reputation assignments here are odd to say the least. They certainly aren't consistent.
I don't think humans are consistent or rational all that often, and I do think people are going to be very, very conservative when it comes to money. Don't underestimate the power of incumbency.
The perception of risk is very important. I understand BTC in a way that very few non-technical people can, though probably only around an average level for a techie, and I'm afraid I wouldn't trust it. The protocol, sure, the community and businesses that have arisen from it, my legal protections when using it etc etc? No way in hell.