News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by codingdave on Thursday April 16, 2015 @02:51PM (#9390020)
I've noticed in recent years that I really cannot parse out quick cuts in movies anymore. For example, I have a very hard time following action sequences in the Marvel movies, and the Transformers movies were just a jumble to me. I mostly don't even bother with trying to watch movies anymore.

I'm probably just getting old...

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by moskie on Thursday April 16, 2015 @02:57PM (#9390061)
These action sequences being a jumbled up mess is a feature, I think. It allows the action on-screen to be visually sloppy and imprecise (thus easier to make), and the audience makes up for it (subconsciously) with their imagination filling in the imperfections with something even better than what they could put on film.

At least, that's what I tell myself. Perhaps we're both just getting old.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by MAGZine on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:06PM (#9390466)
You're exactly right. Not only is the ASL (average shot length) decreasing over time, but flurries of quick shots are great for hiding action that doesn't actually happen. It's definitely can be used as a crutch. Not always, it can accelerate the feeling of action, but often feels lazy, and a disservice to the viewer.

e.g. Citizen Kane had an ASL of 12 seconds. Transformers: Dark side of the moon? 3.4seconds! http://www.cinemetrics.lv/database.php Average ASL in 2006 was actually 2.9s.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by Jtsummers on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:38PM (#9390627)
Comparing to Citizen Kane seems unfair as it's not an action movie. So here are some other action movies. (NB: There are multiple entries for some of these but I'm not listing them all).

  Die Hard      4.5
  Die Hard 2    3.1
  Die Hard 3    1.8
  Armageddon    2.2  -- at least he's ben consistently on the quick side
  Total Recall  3.7  -- original, 1990
  Robocop       3.7  -- original
  Haywire       6
And I keep trying to search for movies they don't have in the database. So certainly for action movies (1980+), at least for some popular ones, the ASL isn't out of the ordinary.

But then I searched for Alfred Hitchcock and got some interesting results. This database has many duplicate entries and some wildly different values. The Skin Game had 3 entries at about the same time (17.1, 17.3, 17.4). However, Rear Window has an entry at 3.7 and another at 8.8, and several at 10.5. I suppose I need to read about their methodology to understand why there's so much variance.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by etcet on Thursday April 16, 2015 @05:07PM (#9390755)
It's crowd sourced. They have software that returns timestamps when you click a button and you use it when watching a movie. It's definitely error prone and the data should be treated as if you got it from Mechanical Turk.

There's so much data in movies that is really hard to get automatically. We should really be digitizing and cataloging old films if we're able. It's hard to find films in the public domain but this is what we should be doing with them: 4k scanning and digitizing. Perform a rough automatic restoration on all frames and audio then put it all online, every frame in 4k, and accept pull requests. During this process all shots and scenes should be accounted for. They are timed with actors and locations marked. Subtitles should have crucial metadata such as the actor speaking the lines. Music and musicians should be identified.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by ctdonath on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:59PM (#9390707)
Dark City has an ASL of 1.8 seconds. And it works.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by snarkyturtle on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:06PM (#9390464)
That's also part of the reason why films are still shot at 24fps even with advanced cameras. You have fast-paced action scenes at 60fps and it doesn't feel as good as 24fps because you have more information. You take away information and add action blur and it feels more "film-like" and more frantic.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by finnh on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:41PM (#9390644)
Yup. I find fight scenes with a bunch of cuts to be boring - and a bit disrespectful, even, of me as a viewer.

Watching a fight with only one or two takes, however, is fantastic. If I recall, the Soderbergh movie "Haywire" was good about this.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by waterlesscloud on Thursday April 16, 2015 @05:10PM (#9390771)
Here's a nice blog post on the fights in JOHN WICK, which are quite fluid. From the viewpoint of a prose writer, but a good take on the visual techniques at work.

http://www.maxgladstone.com/2015/04/fighting-words/

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by MichaelGG on Thursday April 16, 2015 @02:53PM (#9390040)
I think it's more of a style to avoid actually doing choreography of fights and so on. Cut cut cut and zoom in on random things to give the illusion of action instead of having to do the real work.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by bentcorner on Thursday April 16, 2015 @03:03PM (#9390099)
You'll probably enjoy this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1PCtIaM_GQ

In particular, at 5:26, they show how Jackie edits hits to appear twice across cuts to aid in viewability.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by rhino369 on Thursday April 16, 2015 @04:50PM (#9390674)
The whole Every Frame is a Painting series is great.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by jerf on Thursday April 16, 2015 @03:23PM (#9390214)
Well, we're all getting older, sure, but movies really have gotten less coherent in their action scenes. As a test of your "I'm getting old" hypothesis I once stepped through a confusing fight scene in a modern movie at 25% speed through mplayer, and I still could not work out what was happening coherently. Backgrounds are blurs, cuts are these little tiny slices, it's all sound and fury signifying little.

Compare with, say, Terminator 2. I can't quite derive the exact layout of the factory in the final act, but generally speaking I know who's who, where they are, how close they are to each other, etc., all the basics I really ought to know if I'm to be shown tension instead of cinematically simply told there is tension.

Though the Marvel movies have generally been sensible, if fast-paced, in my opinion, so who knows.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by rayiner on Thursday April 16, 2015 @03:18PM (#9390182)
I hate more recent action movies (e.g. Bond movies) for that reason. I can't figure out what's going on. I miss the more sedate pace of 1980's and 1990's action movies. Go back and watch Die Hard or the Fugitive sometime.
Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by Crito on Thursday April 16, 2015 @03:17PM (#9390174)
Those movies in particular are notorious for being a mess in that regard. It's not just you.

Look for action movies where the actors are able to do their own stunts, particularly when they are famed for it or are even athletes. Those movies tend to cut less, unless the director decides to introduce lots of cuts for stylistic reasons.

Re:Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts? by maxxxxx on Thursday April 16, 2015 @05:12PM (#9390778)
I noticed the same in the last Avengers and Superman movies. After a while I had no idea what was going. I am not sure if the action scenes are just some cool looking scenes added to arouse as much emotion as possible without making sense.