Having said that, radio interference is taken pretty seriously (eg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio_Qu...). The free-for-all that we're familiar with is really just a few tiny consumer bands.
DGPS seems like a better idea (even easier to install a virtual border by manually driving the robot around the edge), but would probably require some above-surface beacons. I'd imagine iRobot is trying to cater to the type of people who think grass needs to be mowed every week and wouldn't want even a few beacons sticking up.
Still I'm sure there's another way. And if iRobot wants to win in even just the court of public opinion, they have a steep argument to make.
GPS in your car only appears to be more accurate than that because they're typically "snapping" the GPS signal to an underlying road map.
I wonder if the real reason is that they can't get a patent for simpler methods because it's all been done decades ago?
It really isn't.
the only way to get them to work is to dig a trench along the perimeter of a lawn and install a wire that creates the electronic fence needed to ensure the automaton don’t wander beyond the property line.
If they really want to implement that method, shopping cart locking systems have done it before, and they don't need 6GHz+ RF:
http://www.wired.com/2007/07/hack-remote-sho/