As an example, I have lived with at least one computer my entire life (that I can remember), starting with a Commodore 64. My parents encouraged me to explore, and my dad helped me learn BASIC when I was 9 or 10 (I may have given up without his assistance). The computer was important, but so were my parents. One without the other would have created a very different outcome for me.
Parents of disadvantaged children are less likely to have the time, knowledge, or energy to provide the motivation and assistance to help their children benefit from having a computer. So then, how much social value are we getting when we drop $500 or $1,000 (or more, with support costs) and hand a disadvantaged kid an iPad or a laptop?
In my view, having worked in academic technology, albeit at the college level, we would get better results by providing an excellent technology curriculum, taught by competent teachers, with a low-pressure, low-risk environment (AP Computer Science doesn't work here because disadvantaged kids don't take AP classes). The cost would be about the same, or even less, but in exchange for the money we could get both pieces of the puzzle, hardware (computer labs, imagine in-school hacker spaces), and the knowledge and direction to actually make something of it.
If you want to argue that there are better ways to do all these things, that's fine, but the "only good for consuming content" thing is awfully shallow.
I suppose it depends on what your goal is. If it is to give people a device to use for reading texts then I suppose it's fine. If you want people to reply, or to provide a level playing field outside of school then what I said still applies.
If I were given executive control and a budget, I would work on adding/improving computer labs. For the minority of students who would benefit from a home computer, I would offer a laptop leasing program.
The difference is that the inclusion of the iPad has nothing to do with the iPad. Kids aren't learning about iOS, mobile apps, or how the iPad works. The iPad is a coincidental delivery mechanism.
Contrast that to a computer lab, which is not merely a mechanism to deliver existing math and English content, but also potentially a classroom for computer lessons. It doesn't just provide access. It provides a potential for technology class. That's guided access beyond all the dumb distractions that computers might offer. The iPad is stuck as a coincidental delivery mechanism. You don't even want to do word processing on the iPad.
If at a later time people develop good interactive content that meaningfully surpasses the performance of obvious alternatives, it's not as though your desktop/laptop/computer lab would be any less capable in interactive content. In the meantime, I wonder if the iPad is actually competitive over math textbooks.
More or less, yes: "Under the contract, Pearson was to provide English and math curriculum."
> Why not a website instead
The article says "Deasy had said the technology effort was a civil rights imperative designed to provide low-income students with devices available to their wealthier peers." It's easy for you and me to assume that every man, woman, and child in America has easy access to the web, but it's not necessarily so. Giving a tablet to every single student does seem like a reasonable way to level the playing field. In theory, it would be more portable, simpler to use and maintain, and less abusable than, say, a laptop.
It's unfortunate that things broke down along the way. This could have been a really good idea, if it was implemented properly.