Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing
by 69_years_and on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:03PM
(#9384841)
What's the difference between the tests on earth (as seen on youtube etc) where the engine runs the whole time and seems to display good throttle control and this type of landing?
The Grasshopper tests had a full tank of fuel and (if I recall) additional ballast, to counteract the thrust of the engines. That's what allowed them to hover and perform the various low-velocity translation tests.
Of course, these barge landings are the first high-velocity tests, so there'll be kinks to work out.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing
by 69_years_and on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:34PM
(#9384965)
Thanks, that would explain that.
I was impressed by how small the barge looked compared with the F9 it's clever that the F9 can autonomously target such a small area. If they keep targeting 'Just Read the Instructions' by the time land based landings come to be it will be nailed. Awesome stuff!
Maybe it needs to hover? There must be something that can be squeezed to throttle it down some more. Call the NASCAR guys with their restrictor plate designs.
IMO that landing clearly proved suicide burning is working perfectly fine - they just need to fix something to get rid of the remaining lateral velocity.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing
by monk_e_boy on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:50PM
(#9384789)
Aah, grid fins were the things I was thinking of. That first burn must have some complex maths behind it. Do we know anything of their simulation software?
If the 'x-wings' are what I think you're referring to, they're the landing legs. They are shaped like that to have as minimal impact on the air resistance of the ascending rocket as is possible. They open just before landing.
It can't hover. Even just using a single one of the nine engines, the engine can't be throttled down enough for the rocket to hover. The landing method relies on what they call a 'hover-slam', where they fire the engine during landing to slow it down just before it touches.
Landing this is extremely impressive. It is going four times faster than the speed of sound, and they are landing it on a pad smaller than a football field. Vertical landing of a returning rocket has never been done. It's also the key step in the process of dramatically lowering the cost of spaceflight which could usher in a new era of technology around earth, and on other planets.