News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by hyperbovine on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:34PM (#9384712)
Judging from the ensuing explosion there was still fuel left over.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by sfeng on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:44PM (#9384760)
The RCS thrusters are powered by compressed nitrogen, not the rocket fuel that powers the main engines.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by acadien on Thursday April 16, 2015 @01:19AM (#9386002)
Musk commented himself on twitter something to the effect that the explosion is from the pressure difference of the fuel canister when it is breached. Also the fuel mostly burned at high heat and didn't explode per say.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by darkmighty on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:18PM (#9385145)
Making it a little puzzling ask to why the engines didn't try harder to lower the vertical velocity on approach. Perhaps there are improvements to be made in the control systems.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:15PM (#9385336)
When near fuel exhaustion, the Merlin engine has a thrust to weight ratio above 1. Its firing is timed in order to land at a distance above the landing surface that will allow for a reusable vehicle (close enough to not snap off the landing legs). It carries only enough fuel to do this while also using that same fuel for hydraulically actuating grid fins for aerodynamic control while in a controlled fall to the ground.

Stopping a first stage rocket traveling back to an ocean going barge from supersonic speeds with substantial lateral velocity is hard, no matter what engine is performing its suicide burn while coordinating with RCS thrusters for attitude keeping.

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by justin66 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:00PM (#9385497)
> When near fuel exhaustion, the Merlin engine has a thrust to weight ratio above 1.

Wouldn't it have a thrust to weight ratio well above 1 all the time?

The ratio will be highest just as it's about to run out of fuel. About 160 to 1?

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by jmgao on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:21PM (#9385553)
That's a thrust to weight ratio above 1 when only one of its 9 engines are firing, and running at minimum throttle to boot.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by will_hughes on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:38PM (#9385610)
For the final stage of landing only a single Merlin engine is lit.

They're also limited in how much they can control the throttle on it.

Even at minimum throttle, it's not possible for it to hover.

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by justin66 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:17PM (#9385715)
Odd responses. I guess I shouldn't have phrased my response in the form of a question.

Here's another try:

> When near fuel exhaustion, the Merlin engine has a thrust to weight ratio above 1.

The rocket will always have a thrust to weight ratio well above 1.

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by peeters on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:51PM (#9385805)
I still don't understand the point of your comment then. Yes, the rocket's (potential) TWR will be above 1 at all points of the flight.

What does that have to do with the comment you're replying to? The Falcon 9 has 9 engines. The combined thrust of all of them has to be greater than the weight of the fully loaded rocket. That doesn't mean a single engine will always have more thrust than the weight of the entire rocket.

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by manicdee on Friday April 17, 2015 @02:58AM (#9392610)
While your statement is technically correct in isolation, you are ignoring the context: "the rocket will have a thrust to weight ratio of greater than what is needed to hover and land safely as the Grasshopper demonstrated. Instead the F9R is limited to using the overpowered Merlin as a braking engine with the intent of reaching 0 soeed at 0 altitude with 0 lateral or rotational motion."
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by justin66 on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:19PM (#9397497)
Yeah, it's easy to be a little too conversational sometimes in these comments, which leads to misunderstanding. In retrospect I get the feeling everyone understands the limitations of the hardware here.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by fleitz on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:23PM (#9385170)
I have a feeling their engineers may have considered this. This is after all rocket science.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by darkmighty on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:57PM (#9385285)
I also have this feeling, but from my limited experience with control systems you might want to try the simplest first.

There is a tremendous amount of variables to consider, and the analysis of how to take each into account is non trivial -- if you don't measure some variable precisely enough it might make the whole system less stable, the solution might get worse due to increased computational load, the conditioning might degrade, etc.

So with the number of controls they have and the predictive models available, I'm sure they're actually scrambling to refine their systems right now.

Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by will_hughes on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:40PM (#9385615)
The thrust to weight ratio of a single engine firing is so high that they have no option but to fire at the last moment. Firing for longer would result in the rocket going back up, it can't hover.
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 16, 2015 @02:23AM (#9386169)
You'd be surprised what Bill lets Jeb fly at times... ( ;) ).
Re:Space X CR6 First stage landing by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 16, 2015 @02:21AM (#9386164)
Vertical was fine, it's the residual lateral velocity that tipped over and killed the rocket. Also, I can't find the tweet now (I think it was deleted) but initially Musk said they determined that 'static friction in bipropellant valves introduced a lag into system response that the control system wasn't prepared to handle'.