News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @03:13PM (#9383372)
> Given how much of their traffic and online revenue comes from Google they all agreed, rendering the law moot.

I think "revealing the law was based on a false premise" would be more accurate than "rendering the law moot".

The premise of the law was that by showing snippets, Google was taking something away from the newspapers. If that were true, Google's "give us what we were 'taking' for free or we'll stop taking it" deal would have been rejected out of hand. The fact is, Google was providing the newspapers a valuable service by showing the snippets, which is why, given the choice between Google not doing so at all and Google doing so without paying anything, they chose the latter.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by azakai on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @03:59PM (#9383641)
But the value of that service is because of Google's monopoly position in search in Germany (where its market share is in the 90's last I heard; much higher than in the US).

In other words, the newspapers have no choice but to take whatever terms Google offers them. That's a very bad state of competition in the search market. A search monopoly in Germany gives Google a huge amount of power over not only search but other industries, even the news media.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by shakethemonkey on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:23PM (#9384256)
You either have snippet-royalties or you have viable and useful search engines that operate without a paywall. They are mutually exclusive. If royalty negotiations were required for all content before a snippet could be used, either the search engine will index only a few major players (only the head of the long tail), or the cost of obtaining agreements would exceed any potential revenues. It's not because of a monopoly player in the market, the dysfunction applies to all potential search engines. And the minor players in such a regime would be even at a greater disadvantage, lacking the resources to come to arrangements. Be careful what you wish for.