News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by nathanm412 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @12:57PM (#9382341)
Softcard was shutting down anyways. They really never recovered from heavily investing in branding a product named ISIS and then having to change their name after that budget had been spent. On top of that, the early adopters that would have spread the word of the product were annoyed that the phone carriers were actively blocking Google Wallet installations in order to push ISIS adoption in the beginning. Google Wallet had to change business models and use a reloadable card because the carriers prevented Google from using the secure element on NFC to store the user's actual credit card on their own device. After Softcard began to fold, Google just bought what was left.
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:05PM (#9382404)
Nobody cared about Google Wallet. It was never more than a tech industry niche item (aside from being an account for Play Store purchases), and phone carriers only blocked it because Google was trying to create a monopoly.

If you understand the history behind the secure element, you'd realize that it was those phone carriers which forced Google to adopt HCE, which allows payment options. Google's plan was to be the sole payment provider across the entire industry.

Source: http://www.androidpolice.com/2013/05/01/a-brief-history-of-v...

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by magicalist on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:10PM (#9382452)
You're off in bizarro land here. The brave carriers blocking evil Google's payment monopoly by allowing only ISIS payments on their phone? I know you're trolling the rest of this thread, but seriously?

That article is not even a source for what you're claiming! It just says Verizon wasn't illegally acting when it blocked Google Wallet on its phones.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by Oletros on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:13PM (#9382467)
Looking all of their posts in that thread it is clear how much loves Google and how far goes to spin and bend reality
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:15PM (#9382484)
Read the article, magicalist. Particularly the bottom few paragraphs. Google mandated exclusive use of the Secure Element for the payment system on Android. This would have prevented carriers from offering a competing payment service.

In short, carriers were not being greedy by blocking Wallet. Google was being greedy by designing Wallet. Carriers, if anything, saved us from a Google Wallet monopoly. Now anyone can make an app that uses NFC.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by magicalist on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:36PM (#9382640)
> Google mandated exclusive use of the Secure Element for the payment system on Android

The article's only claim in that area is that the Secure Element can only contain the credentials for one credit card (which wouldn't incidentally, lock developers out of using NFC). I'm not sure if that's right, but even assuming that, it appears to be a function of the hardware, not some evil plan to monopolize the phone.

The carriers only saved us in the sense that they forced Google to design around the Secure Element (which, notably, they could have also done themselves, another hole in your narrative...), giving a pure software solution and allowing Google Wallet to not ever be blocked on a hardware level.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:40PM (#9382669)
I'm guessing you missed this bit?

> Google Wallet is doing something few apps do - asking for direct, exclusive access to a secure piece of hardware in the phone. Not only that, once Google takes over the secure element, it wants total control. Because of the security concerns (and related technical difficulties) involved in sharing a secure element, Wallet and only Wallet is able to utilize the internal secure element on a Wallet-enabled device. That means Google is directly managing every layer of the process.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by magicalist on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @02:27PM (#9383044)
No, that's exactly what I'm referring to. The article claims that the Secure Element can only be used by one set of credentials. If that's true, that's not locking out other people, that's just using the thing. Note also the "asking" part of that quote: Google Wallet wouldn't have used the Secure Element if you never used Google Wallet.

Meanwhile I'm still not sure how you're rationalizing the carriers as savior thing when they turned around and did exactly that dastardly thing (using the Secure Element) while also mandating that no one be able to decline the use of their payment system and use a different app. It was either ISIS or nothing.

Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @02:52PM (#9383231)
Google Wallet was intended to be installed by default on all their devices, via their MADA agreement to push Google Apps onto Android devices.
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by nevi-me on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:03PM (#9384102)
Some proof? I live in South Africa, and last I checked I couldn't use Wallet. Was Google going to force Samsung to install Wallet on my phone? As far as I know, all the Google Apps that came with my phone are on someone else's phone in Australia or US.
Re:EU Formally Accuses Google of Antitrust Violations by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:39PM (#9384358)
Wallet is definitely still US-specific. As is Apple Pay, and was Softcard. I have no idea when and if any of these companies will ever expand NFC payments internationally, though some countries have local providers.