Whether an improved competitive marketplace would result from the changes and yield long-term benefits that offset the cost of those impairments may be a worthwhile debate, but its not a debate you can even have honestly without recognizing the impairments.
Google's "openness" is what I refer to as "just enough rope to hang yourself with". They only are open insofar as they know you can't successfully compete with them.
In iOS there's no chance of installing an alternate app store by default, and yet with Anroid Amazon was able to make the Kindle devices (fire phone; tablet) that run Android without any hint of Google services.
A user can already choose to purchase a device without those services, it just happens users don't want to. I, as a user, enjoy having Google's services and enjoy that I can install alternatives if I so desire (like alternate and better email apps).
That's one of the reasons I don't use iOS
Android includes (or at least used to include) a generic email app called Email.
> It would be "impaired" if part of the setup process was to select an app store[0], a browser[1], and a maps app[1]?
You can have all of those, and more, with custom ROMs like Cyanogenmod, or even with AOSP alone.
Amazon's devices do not have any of Google's services.
However, it's fine... Google isn't doing it for anti-competitive reasons, they're doing it because all of the Google services are needed to have a stable system.
Various custom roms let you install only a subset of the Google services, and that option invariably leads to bugs. Of course Google shouldn't want to support that.
Your complaint is akin to saying that firefox is anti-competitive because to use their XUL interpreter I have to use their mozilla compiler and rendering suite.
There's plenty of freedom already on Android. Plenty of third-party manufacturers bundle their own app stores and users can create and/or install plenty of alternatives.
This is an entirely different story than on iOS.
But that doesn't mean that every argument that leads to that conclusion must be valid! The statement I was replying to was not. Amazon devices prove the point: as they don't comply with Google's requirements, they are unable to ship any of the Google's proprietary services even as part of the process antsar was suggesting in the GP comment ("part of the setup process [could be] to select an app store" [from a selection including the play store]).
Android would be "impaired" if it shipped a general-purpose mail client rather than one designed specifically for Gmail?
It would be "impaired" if part of the setup process was to select an app store[0], a browser[1], and a maps app[1]?
That sounds more like "consumer empowerment" than "impairment" to me.
[0] Google Play, F-Droid, Amazon's app store, etc
[1] Just show that category of programs from the aforementioned app store