Flat isn't the simplification -- elimination of the billion deductions is the simplification.
> Flat isn't the simplification -- elimination of the billion deductions is the simplification.
If you have deductions, it isn't a flat tax. "Flat" typically implies both rate and lack of deductions.
If you took current government revenue from income taxes as a percentage of total personal income and just used that as the flat tax rate, that would indeed be quite unreasonable, mostly because that revenue number is far too high. On the other hand, a flat rate in the 4-5% range might not be unreasonable.
Or, alternatively, a simple formula that would still count as "flat tax":
tax = flat_rate * max(income - floor, 0)
Where "floor" is a threshold below which you pay no taxes. That would address the set of people for whom even a tiny increase in taxes could make the difference between making ends meet and not.So yes, a large percentage of people are just getting the standard deduction.
So, yes, plenty of people in the "we can afford expensive houses" category are in position to deduct. Majority of the nation? Not so much.
That much I absolutely agree with. A flat tax would require a single tax form the size of a business card.
> The percentage of people who save money by itemizing deductions is extremely small, as is the percentage who claim (or are eligible for) any of the more generous deductions.
Not true at all. Anyone who owns a home itemizes to deduct interest. Anyone who pays enough state taxes itemizes because you can deduct state tax payments on your federal taxes.
I do agree that taxes should be drastically simplified, but in the process they would also need to be lowered so that the average person pays the same or less in taxes as they would have with today's high taxes and deductions.