News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jaron Lanier: "Long Live Closed-Source Software!" by gojomo on Sunday December 30, 2007 @08:20PM (#93777)
Another way to think about whether closed-source sometimes has a place:

What if, by law, all software had to be open-source? Do you expect there would be more, or less, innovation? More, or less, diversity of implementation?

(I love open source but think the prospect of outsized returns from secret/proprietary codebases attracts some innovation and diversity we wouldn't otherwise have, especially in places where software creates a core competitive advantage -- investing, Google-scale cluster operations, domain-specific expert systems, etc.)

Re:Jaron Lanier: "Long Live Closed-Source Software!" by jsnx on Monday December 31, 2007 @02:40AM (#93858)
Well, what if, by law, you had to ship the source when you ship the software? That's as much as any Open Source license demands.

Software As A Service remains completely protected -- would it be so bad if people who wanted to cash in had to offer services instead of products?