News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by kazinator on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @05:19PM (#9377436)
I don't think you can dismiss all political extremists this easily.

Political extremists sometimes disagree with the morality of the individual transactions contained within a policy.

"If you only understood the complex effects of the policy, you would agree" is not a valid counter-argument to somehow who thinks it has immoral underpinnings, because you are asking that person to basically cave in to the idea that the end justifies the means: "If only your thinking wasn't clouded by a naive illusion of understanding, you would see that desirable ends are achieved, and therefore you would accept the means."

Moral shortcuts in reasoning are in fact valid, and we see examples of this in law. A judge can hand down a sentence in a complex case which contains 2500 pages of evidence, without knowing the entire contents. He or she just has to know about specific law-breaking actions. That judge does not have an "illusion of understanding", and is not ignorant of that the crime had some benefits to someone. Those benefits were improperly achieved through the perpetration of a crime so they do not matter.

This is a useful analogy. A political extremist sees him or herself as a judge, and the proponent of a policy he or she disagrees with as wrongdoers, and the benefits of the policy (whatever they are, complexity being irrelevant) as being the result of wrong actions.

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by baddox on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @05:36PM (#9377537)
> "If you only understood the complex effects of the policy, you would agree" is not a valid counter-argument to somehow who thinks it has immoral underpinnings, because you are asking that person to basically cave in to the idea that the end justifies the means: "If only your thinking wasn't clouded by a naive illusion of understanding, you would see that desirable ends are achieved, and therefore you would accept the means."

Doesn't that show the fundamental weakness of moral arguments? If Bob opposes a policy on moral grounds, but you convince Bob that the consequences of the policy would be overwhelmingly good by both of our standards (e.g. a reduction in crime or poverty), wouldn't you expect Bob to change his opinion about the policy (and perhaps concoct some moral justification)?

I find that most people who hold a moral position also have (what they believe are) strong arguments for why the consequences of breaking that moral position will be bad. And yet, most of them are not consequentialists, and are very resistant to consequentialism. Doesn't that seem too convenient?

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by kazinator on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @07:19PM (#9377954)
Rather, I think the problem is that some moralists have odd or outright bad morals.

What I mean by bad morals is ones that have to do with controlling aspects of other people's lives that don't affect others.

For example, say, opposition to two people of the same sex being married, which is purely their business. One justification is that it takes away from the "sanctity" of marriage, which somehow takes something away from the marriage of some opposite-sex couple who don't even know those two men.

Another example is appeals to traditions. Doing something is right because it's "always" been done that way.

On a related note, some moralists simply oppose change as a kind of moral. Change is bad. Lack of change is good! Anything that forces me to make an effort and learn something new or adjust is immoral; things staying the same is moral.

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by A_COMPUTER on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @12:12AM (#9378839)
>controlling aspects of other people's lives that don't affect others[...]opposition to two people of the same sex being married, which is purely their business.

It is blowing my mind that you can write this immediately following a massive national controversy over Indiana's Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the ability of religious businesses to decline service to same-sex marriages.

>some moralists simply oppose change as a kind of moral.

Conservatives argue that a working society is an accumulation of attributes that have stood the test of time and reached a stable equilibrium with each other, and that making even small changes have to be carefully examined because small changes can have large repercussions. There are congenital flaws in conservative thinking with regard to how and when you recognize change is finally needed, but the principle is a lot more sane than the other extreme.

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by kbutler on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:32PM (#9378212)
How direct or concentrated an "affect others" criteria do you require?

With US tax law, taxpayers do subsidize all married filing jointly couples.

If you believe that the aggregate actions of others will cause billions of dollars of harm and millions of deaths, should you seek to prevent those actions?

If so, I expect you're opposed to smoking, gun ownership, drug use, alcohol consumption, and non-monogamous sex.

It's really easy to dismiss harms or rights you don't agree with.

If you think a fetus could not possibly have rights until birth, allowing abortion is easy. If you think an unborn child has rights, the child's death weighs strongly against potential harm to the mother.

> some moralists simply oppose change

Any examples? Everyone I've encountered wants some change, even if it's "back to how it was" in many areas.

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by jmnicolas on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:24AM (#9380443)
Since when being against same sex marriage is political extremism ? I'm under the impression that for liberals, everything that is against their views is extremism ...
Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by xrange on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:07PM (#9378135)
"...This could explain why well-educated, intelligent people, all across the political spectrum, so often make the unspoken assumption that good intentions and well-crafted words are sufficient for making good public policy"

http://jaltcoh.blogspot.com/2015/04/what-are-we-doing-when-w...

Re:Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Under... by ptaipale on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @12:49AM (#9378929)
Thank you, that was a gem. "But that's the assumption being made whenever anyone argues in favor of a law by referring to the righteous aspirations underlying it, without contemplating whether the process initiated by the text of the law could lead to results that are at odds with those aspirations."

Good intentions, sometimes quite counter-productive end results.