News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Recycling Myth by gaius on Thursday November 12, 2009 @07:24AM (#937609)
Errm, actually (modern) militaries are highly decentralized. The corporal on the ground has a great deal of latitude and is expected to show initiative and creativity.

Contrast that with the highly centralized militaries of WW1 - the attempted result wasn't "get bogged down for 4 years while our troops are mass-slaughtered".

Re:The Recycling Myth by barrkel on Thursday November 12, 2009 @08:28AM (#937687)
I think you've missed my point. The article writer made a ridiculously strong claim: that no centralized structure ever worked. Only a single counterexample is needed to show that this is a dodgy claim, but counterexamples to this aren't rare, they're abundant. In particular, any time the efficiency costs of centralization are less than the transaction costs of decentralized parts cooperating, centralization is a win. There's a reason we've evolved brains.

Coming up with examples where decentralization beat centralization, on the other hand, proves nothing.