News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by humanfromearth on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @07:51AM (#9373468)
Given the underrepresentation of women in tech I think I'm ok with them being chosen over satisfying your ambitions.

Also working hard to better yourself is a continuous process and it doesn't stop when you get hired at BigCorp, continue doing so and you'll get results no matter your gender.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by smtddr on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:15AM (#9373582)
>>Given the underrepresentation of women in tech I think I'm ok with them being chosen over satisfying your ambitions.

This sounds like Affirmative-action; while having good intentions did not work out quite like they hoped. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action , search for the word "Negative".

Also, I wouldn't want my coworkers thinking I only got the job because I'm a black male. Even I myself don't like the idea that I might have gotten something only because someone else saw me as a charity case or I'm just the "token black guy" so the company can prove "See? We got a black guy! We're cool & hip now!" Replace "black male" with "woman" and I still believe my statement is true for most people.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by humanfromearth on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:49AM (#9373770)
Sharing a personal anecdote:

I'm somebody who was part of this affirmative action population. I come from the poorest country in Europe called Moldova, the unemployment is high, education low, your typical eastern-european anti-intelectual culture, you get the idea.. Anyway.. when I was 15 I got a scholarship in Romania because there were quotas for us 'moldavians'. At the time Romania was not much better off than Moldova, but certainly when it comes to math and CS to me at least it looked years ahead of the programs we had in Moldova! So I packed my bags and left for a much better education and what I would say now without reservation: a better life. Looking back I think I was very lucky to have gotten the education and exposure to an environment with great teachers/programmers. Maybe I could have succeeded in Moldova, who knows.. It's possible I suppose, but unlikely.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by huxley on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @10:28AM (#9374490)
People who don't think you deserve a job will find a reason, any reason for their belief, even if you are the smartest person in the room, you will always be the "token black guy" for a significant percentage of people with or without an affirmative action programme.

And counter to your point, if you read the article, you'll find that affirmative action programmes have been very successful in improving participation rates and shrinking the wage gaps. Not to the point of equity, but an improvement. (Sidenote: if you search for Positive, you'll find twice as many as Negative)

Thomas Sowell--who is proposes several of the arguments against affirmative action in the wikipedia article-- is extremely intelligent, but if you follow his work you'll see that he's incapable of supporting anything that goes against the idea of ideologically pure free market systems.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by humanfromearth on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:33AM (#9373662)
Ok. I see your point. Positive discrimination is harmful, but I think it only applies when it's abused. From my vantage point I don't think we are there.

Do you think that any amount of positive discrimination is harmful for a given population?

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by dylukes on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:49AM (#9373763)
Ask someone anywhere in the lower-middle range who's sent a kid (moreso boy than girl) to college recently how they feel about whether we're there or not.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by cmiles74 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:28AM (#9374020)
I'm pretty sure a homogenous group of males with the same ethnicity will almost exclusively hire more males that "fit with their culture" and can "quickly get up to speed with the rest of their team".

I'm interested in hearing alternatives to an "affirmative action like" approach that would be effective.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by ra1n85 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:03AM (#9373514)
>Given the underrepresentation of women in tech I think I'm ok with them being chosen over satisfying your ambitions.

There is so much wrong with this. You do no justice to anyone when you discount merit in the pursuit of ham-handed ratios.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by themartorana on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:30AM (#9373646)
Agreed. A company that hires no women will likely be at a disadvantage to the competition. Hiring diversely is an asset. While I'd like to fast-forward to a time where gender is in fact equal in most things, I think a much better way to start is to remove gender, race, etc. from college and work applications altogether.

What would happen if we let merit and drive determine outcomes above all other things? Maybe there are caveats I'm not considering.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by dylukes on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:43AM (#9373717)
More likely than not people start yelling loudly about who's advertising their skills better.

In the end not enough businesses and institutions are equipped to accurately assess skill. So rather than being hired based on skill, what you'd really be hired based on is perceived skill.

The people who can sell themselves and spin their skills will continue to thrive, the people who can't but have skills will find niches to do their work, and the people who don't have either will complain that the first two groups are being "pushy" or have an unfair advantage because they're selling themselves better.

Something like that.

Edit: even if we could measure skill... how? I don't suspect it's always an objectively measurable thing. e.g. most people who seek out psychiatric help want to find someone who is good fit for them and they can trust and talk to, not the "state's top ranked psychiatrist" (who is inherently intimidating).

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by kaybe on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:32AM (#9374054)
Here is a relevant paper for this:

https://www.nber.org/papers/w5903 (1997)

Essentially, they found that switching to blind auditing for orchestra musician positions raised the ratio of women hired severalfold. Thus, people' skill is (was?) rated lower if it is known they are female.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by smorrow on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:51AM (#9373783)
"I think a much better way to start is to remove gender, race, etc. from college and work applications altogether."

There's such a thing as interviews, though.

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by jstedfast on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:04AM (#9373518)
What happened to hiring people based on merit?
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by briandear on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:32AM (#9373654)
There are folks of certain political persuasions that would suggest that you are ignorant of the struggle and your white privilege is manifesting itself. This is exactly why I don't understand the "we need a woman president" malarkey. No, we need competent people regardless of their color or genatalia. This idea that we 'need' more this or more that is actually sexist and/or racist by definition.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by dylukes on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:32AM (#9373653)
Something like this became a bit of a meme.

http://geekfeminism.org/2009/11/29/questioning-the-merit-of-...

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by cmiles74 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:34AM (#9374063)
In my opinion, it's not as easy as it sounds. We all have biases and prejudices, some that we are aware of and some that we don't even notice.

Personally, I think you need a pretty mixed group of people in charge of hiring in order to get anywhere near to a fair and balanced process. It's too easy to discount racist or sexist hiring practices (either subconcious or overt) under the guise of wanting people who "fit with the team's culture".

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:08AM (#9373889)
You might as well ask 'what happened to bigfoot'.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by AlexandrB on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:20AM (#9373960)
When has this ever happened in reality? Every other week I see a HN link about how hard it is to actually identify talent and how companies continue to screw it up (hence: hire slow, fire fast). Many hires (especially of A peoople) tend happen on the basis of personal networks as well.

While merit plays a role, pretending that before affirmative action hiring was merit-based is naive at best.

Given this, I'd like you to please consider that the perception that a specific gender or race is worse at tech may be a bigger influence in an interview than the objective merit or lack thereof that candidate has (something that's impossible to measure in knowledge-work anyways).

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by weland on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:31AM (#9373651)
It became bad PR.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:34AM (#9374068)
LinkedIn exists because hiring people on merit doesn't exist.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by alex-g on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:30AM (#9374037)
Systemic biases complicate the assessment of merit.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by steamy on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:01AM (#9373506)
Given the underrepresentation of women in tech I think I'm ok with them being chosen over satisfying your ambitions.

What's this supposed to mean? Is this some sort of reverse sexism? Reparation in kind for the gentle sex?

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by cmiles74 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:30AM (#9374041)
Perhaps the poster was pointing out that the under-representation of women in technology is an actual, real world problem that needs to be solved. This one male's ambitions is not really comparable.
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by thsealienbstrds on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @02:35PM (#9376348)
What do you mean, women are under-represented in tech? As in: it needs to be 50/50 men and women? Or as in: the ratio of men/women working in tech should reflect the ratio of men/women who'd like to have a tech job?
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by steamy on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:39AM (#9374106)
How many female participants we got here on HN?

Is it safe to say that male members outnumber their female counterparts?

If so, what's the reason or the catalyst behind this disparity in interest and participation rate between sexes?

Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by timwaagh on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @08:07AM (#9373534)
its called feminism and its pretty scary
Re:Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions by josinalvo on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:04AM (#9373861)
before you downvote this preciding comment (or mine, for that matter), allow me a challenge: If you pick 10 woman who self-identified as feminists at random, how many do you predict will find this 2:1 ratio a good thing ?

I predict 7 or more.