Re:Ask YC: How to prevent social news sites from devolving?
by queensnake on Sunday December 30, 2007 @05:32PM
(#93736)
But you might frustrate newbies ("I can't get links onto the front page! Too snobby for me, I'm going elsewhere!"). And users are ultimately ad-bait at places like Reddit. If Reddit could get Digg's traffic by losing whatever quality they have, they would in a heartbeat (or Conde-Nast would make them), whatever regret the original developers might feel about it.
Re:Ask YC: How to prevent social news sites from devolving?
by robg on Sunday December 30, 2007 @08:34PM
(#93784)
All the newbie has to do is submit content that resonates with the community. Think of it as a game that they can play by choice. Sooner or later they'll figure out what fits. And I'd venture that people do this anyways. It's just that the power of the original community voice got watered down by treating every vote equally.
I'd argue we expect that implicit hierarchy to provide a trustworthiness. If someone's submissions aren't being up-voted, they have the choice to either conform or find a community better suited to their interests. To the extent they match the community principles is the extent to which their own voice becomes heard and amplified.