You seem to be arguing that small companies should have special dispensation versus large companies to circumvent immigration laws in order to lower their labor costs.
If you think small companies have a thumb on the scale, then give them a thumb on the scale. e.g. special tax incentives for hiring. And in fact small businesses do get thumbs on the scale from the government all the time. e.g. government solicitations favoring (by mandate) small and minority or female-owned businesses, SBA loans, etc. If you think they should get more, by all means argue that, but why at the expense of the US labor force?
I simply argued that OP's proposal - which is a not a law - would put companies with scarcer funds in disadvantage against bigger companies with more money to burn. I'm all for a free market, but what the OP is proposing is a market distortion since there are a limited number of visas.
Anyhow, you do realize that H1B filling requires a certified LCA, don't you?
- It would alleviate (though probably not solve) the downward pressure on salaries.
- It would ensure that companies are well motivated to find domestic workers since they would, theoretically, be cheaper.
- It would ensure that H-1B's go to the people who would add the most value to the economy (or else the company would be less competitive due to overpaying).
- It would favor the most talented foreigners rather than putting them in a random lottery with new grads.
- It would allocate the H-1B's to the companies that need them most (since they're offering the most money)
- It would maximize the future tax take of the US government (maximum income => maximum taxes paid)
Ironically, this might have prevented me from getting my own H-1B as I got it fairly early in my career.