News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by kmm on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:23PM (#9371547)
Interestingly, RKV's travel at speeds that are apparently faster than light, because they immediately follow the light they emit. If an RKV was launched towards us from Sirius at 99% of the speed of light, the news of that launch would reach us 10 years later, with the missile following merely a month later. Thus, if we could track the missile, it would appear to cross 10 light years of distance in that month, at an apparent speed of almost 100c. We can see a related effect in real life with jets coming from black holes and other sources ejecting material at high speeds[1]. This is of course not true superluminal motion, but an optical illusion.

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superluminal_motion

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by darkmighty on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:36PM (#9371806)
Also interestingly, this accumulation of energy in front of the vehicle is the cause of Sonic booms. Acoustic waves, and pressure dispersion in general, get accumulated in front of the craft, momentarily creating enormous resistance and temperatures as it passes the speed of sound. Of course the accumulation of light is different in that it can't affect the vehicles themselves due to the principle of relativity (constant speed of light for all inertial observers).
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by jakeogh on Monday April 13, 2015 @05:18PM (#9370583)
(Caution; dont click unless you have atleast an hour to kill)

http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacegunexotic....

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:22PM (#9371151)
Sigh, I should have heeded your warning. My productivity is not looking too good today.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by henrikschroder on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:45PM (#9371995)
And it links to TV-tropes, oh noooooo.....
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by lotsofmangos on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:14PM (#9371123)
It is also referred to in 'The Algebraist' by Ian M. Banks.

It is mentioned that the Dweller species have a habit of taking a very long revenge against any other species stupid enough to wipe a community of them out. So a few generations after a species has completely forgotten about the load of strange jellyfish they killed off in their local gas giant, a shit-ton of sand and gravel comes through their system at a significant fraction of the speed of light.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by theoh on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:08PM (#9371316)
I suspect the initial post was a response to Charlie Stross's remarks about existential risks: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2015/04/on-the-g...

Since we live in the twitteresque dark ages there's no way to know. Vannevar Bush would be turning in his grave.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by dougk16 on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:22PM (#9371364)
Question: The article mentions that a 1kg projectile travelling at 99% of the speed of light would have such and such more explosive energy than the most powerful nuclear bob ever detonated. I don't doubt the math, but would the destructive effects (e.g. to a city) of such a projectile weapon actually equal those of a nuclear bomb? I'm not talking about the radiation and such in the aftermath, just the explosion itself. Wouldn't the projectile basically go straight through a planet?

Edit: I suppose the shockwave from entering the atmosphere would cause a bit of a rucus too...still interested in any responses.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by blackstache on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:30PM (#9371384)
This might give the beginnings of an idea of what would happen:

https://what-if.xkcd.com/1/

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by dougk16 on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:31PM (#9371572)
Interesting, thanks for the link. Intuitively it still seems like much of the energy from the projectile would be absorbed deep in the Earth as it traveled through. For sure it would cause some damage, but it still seems like a nuclear bomb would have a higher effective energy, as far as the tactical goal of taking out a city or something.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:02PM (#9371659)
You can adjust effective penetration depth by the "density" (read, mass per unit cross-sectional area) of the projectile.

You could go anywhere from an osmium needle through to a Mylar disk.

Another relevant XKCD: https://what-if.xkcd.com/20/

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by mikeash on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:25PM (#9371554)
From the perspective of the RKV, the Earth will look like a cloud of fast-moving subatomic particles irradiating it with a power that substantially outshines the sun. The particles that make up the RKV will collide with and impart their energy to bits of the Earth (or its atmosphere) in pretty short order. Those will impart their energy to other bits of the Earth, and so forth, forming a normal (aside from scale) shockwave made up of bits of Earth (or its atmosphere) and bits of the vaporized RKV.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by svachalek on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:51PM (#9371444)
The recent articles on Artificial Superintelligence have got me thinking about interstellar MAD. It seems that once you have ASI you really have the capability to do anything within the laws of physics because if there's anything you don't know how to do, you just add intelligence until you do. If so, it seems that primitive civilizations can become enormous, exponentially expanding threats to established civilizations in relatively no time at all, and in fact they are extremely vulnerable if they choose not to, not only to established players but to any new ones that come along.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by api on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:02PM (#9371483)
A little off topic but...

"you just add intelligence until you do"

So many assumptions. I'd challenge everyone to look deeply into learning theory and combinatorics. We have no reason to believe that intelligence is something you can just scale up without bound, and many reasons to believe otherwise.

For starters: nature "invented" intelligence hundreds of millions of years ago with the evolution of neural nets, and it's a powerful adaptation that confers significant advantage. Why are we the only intelligence with our level of analytical capability on Earth? If it were so easy to "just add intelligence," almost every large animal in nature should be capable of language, mathematics, and logic by now.

As someone who spent many years studying AI, machine learning, combinatorics, evolutionary theory, and related topics, some of the stuff that's been flying around about AI recently is making me itch.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by InclinedPlane on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:01PM (#9371654)
Precisely. So much theory around super-intelligences does very little to actually address the nature of intelligence or awareness, it merely treats intelligence like horsepower or computing cycles. This despite the fact that we've spent almost a century proving that intelligence differs greatly from raw computing power, and is a far more complex and subtle thing.

We don't know what the returns on computational power are in regards to intelligence levels, it may actually be non-linear (one way or the other). Or it may be mostly uncorrelated.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by api on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @02:08AM (#9372382)
All that is true and more. Intelligence is bad enough, but start talking about consciousness and sentience and we don't even know what we don't know. Our understanding there is so spotty there are major camps of people who want to just chicken out on the whole question and claim thes things do not exist. Humans don't like to admit they don't understand things... Threatens the ego.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by 6d0debc071 on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:19PM (#9371531)
> For starters: nature "invented" intelligence hundreds of millions of years ago with the evolution of neural nets, and it's a powerful adaptation that confers significant advantage. Why are we the only intelligence with our level of analytical capability on Earth?

Lots of animals seem to lack the ability to use fine tools and have limited vocal ranges that would make communication far more difficult. I'm inclined to question the 'significant advantage' part in its unqualified form.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by api on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:40AM (#9372317)
Strategic thinking, categorization, and the recognition of complex environmental patterns are among the abilities that would be very valuable even for mutes without opposable thumbs.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by 6d0debc071 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @05:12AM (#9372977)
That sounds reasonable, but I'm not sure what those things translate into. Take something that's reasonably intelligent - a wolf for instance. How, for most of its evolutionary history, would being able to recognise complex environmental patterns, as a human would, have made it successful enough to offset the energy cost of doing so? What part of the energy of the system accessible with their abilities are they missing?
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by seanmcdirmid on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:11PM (#9371920)
We killed off all animals that could conceivably compete with us on intelligence (Neanderthals, various other hominids). The advantage of being first os that there is no need for second.

Also, there are other animals that approach our intelligence and are probably sentient. They are just a bit behind us, but enough so that we dont recognize them as so (the pack of communication is also an issue).

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by RickHull on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:37PM (#9371813)
An analogy might be made in terms of escape velocity. For the longest time, we hurled stones at targets in trees and towers. However, in the times leading up to WWII, we (Germans, mostly) began to sense that we could launch objects at the Moon or Mars with plausibly incremental improvements. A tipping or inflection point is reached where things go all zoomy and nonlinear.

70 years later, we might be entering that era for intelligence. These sorts of things are not easily rejected by looking at historical trajectories.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by darkmighty on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:47PM (#9371839)
You are using the historical trajectory of rockets in a way to prove your point :)

But looking precisely at rockets, there was a boom in technology where the distances and velocities we could go increased exponentially until the tech matured, and now it's settled and still pretty expensive to go up there.

In fact, this trend seems common with technologies (rapid growth until a wall is reached). I wish I had a link to the graphs I have in mind that make this argument.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by api on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:39AM (#9372309)
You can scale a rocket by mostly just making it bigger. I'm not at all convinced you can do this with intelligence. It sssumes many things: intelligence is one thing, no new problems of a fundamentally different order appear with scale, and there are no scaling laws that apply to intelligence.

Of those assumptions, the one that seems most common around here is that intelligence is one thing.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by maxpupmax on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:37PM (#9371586)
I'm interested. Could you provide a starting point for reading? Preferably with extensive references!
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by api on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:44AM (#9372328)
I wish I had the time to write a book on it. It's a deeply esoteric subject though, and I am too insanely busy right now.

Better yet, I really wish someone far more up to date than I am who is actually working today in the field would take up the cause of airing out some of this silliness. I considered it harmless up to the point I started reading actual calls to regulate or even ban basic CS research. If I see any more of that stuff there is one person I know that I might email and try to convince to do it. The last thing we need is to shut down one of our most productive areas of innovation with baseless fear mongering built on towers of wobbly assumptions and cheesy sci fi scenarios.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by quanticle on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:56PM (#9371281)
Gwern has a a good write-up about various "realistic" scenarios for interstellar war: http://www.gwern.net/Colder%20Wars
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by t0mas88 on Monday April 13, 2015 @03:08PM (#9369703)
The page mentions accelerating over a longer distance, but wouldn't that defeat the undetectability of the whole thing?
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:09PM (#9371108)
Not necessity.

Imagine a spacecraft using a standard inertial propulsion system. It shoots mass one way and it goes in the opposite direction. If it had something like a thrust signature, it would be in exactly the wrong direction for the intended target to see, add in a shroud and it would impossible to detect unless the target had sensors in other systems perpendicular and in between the launch site and target site.

Even if detected, what could be done? A planet is not going to change it's trajectory, and even if they fry it with some sort of energy weapon, it would still maintain it's velocity and the associated energy.

Truly, in a universe with advanced and aggressive space faring species, a planet would be about the most unsafe place you could be, it would be ridiculous easy for said advanced space faring species to destroy/make uninhabitable a planet. And you would hardly even need a RKV to do it.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:27PM (#9371752)
You'd see the "bow wave" regardless - the energy imparted as the impactor hits interstellar medium. To a first approximation, that's on the order of 67kw / m^2 at 0.9c ([1]), which is... non-negligible. And in practice, you'd notice the occasional flashes when you hit a grain of dust.

This cannot be solved by a shroud, as you'd then see the interstellar medium hitting the shroud instead.

The best response to something like this would be a whipple shield. Except you don't need an actual shield. Just drop a couple stages of a bunch of chaff in its trajectory, or a bunch of spin-stabilized mylar disks. Even ball bearings would be too much. You don't need to stop it, "just" diffuse it enough so that the atmosphere can handle it.

[1]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%28%281+-+0.9^2%29^-0.5..., Assuming ~1 atom/cc, 90% hydrogen 10% helium

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:32PM (#9371966)
True, but I think a lot of people here are assuming something like .9C or the like when the reality is you nothing nearly that high.

1000 tons at .1c is 9818 megatons, which would be roughly the size of a US air craft carrier. The bow shock would be much less and the I'm assuming it would be using some sort of magnetic scoop ramjet would would channel interstellar medium to the propulsion system rather than striking the bow.

With a stealthy design, the thing would be very difficult if not impossible to detect, barring some sort of entirely need detection method.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:46PM (#9372001)
You use a magnetic scoop ramjet, great. Now you have cyclotron radiation. Congratulations, now you're even more detectable!

And even at 0.1c, you encounter a grain of sand, that's, what, ~23MJ of energy released.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:36AM (#9372131)
You got me there, good comments. Thanks.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @02:00PM (#9376114)
Oh yeah, and two other things.

Your 1000 tons at 0.1c is going to have a whole lot more cross-sectional area than, say, 4 tons at 0.9c. At least the cube root of 250 times, or ~6.3x.

You'll also have, what, 11x more time to react to it at a given distance.

Neither of these compensate entirely, but both of these are compensatory effects.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @04:53PM (#9377265)
More cross-sectional area because of lorentz contraction or just looking at the mass-surface area / kinetic energy ratio?
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @06:27PM (#9377764)
Whoops, I messed up. Try 250^(2/3) times, instead.

(I was intending to assume constant density and shape, but forgot to turn that into cross-sectional area as opposed to radius.)

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by Terr_ on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:40PM (#9371223)
> Even if detected, what could be done?

A large-scale Whipple Shield, maybe? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whipple_shield)

Throw a small moon into its path and engage it from as far away as possible. You'll end up with a lot of smaller slower pieces over a wider area.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:49PM (#9371845)
The biggest problem with Whipple shields with relativistic projectiles is that the projectiles literally don't have time to react. Partly because of the speed itself, partly because of time dilation.

You need to throw enough at it that a large chunk of the nuclei in the impactor are hit by nuclei of the atoms you are throwing at it - not an insignificant feat. Small moon may work.

Anything less and yes, it's rapidly expanding into a cloud of gas, but nowhere near fast enough. It'll hit the target well before it dissipates significantly if you're not careful.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:31PM (#9371389)
That might work, it would have to be detected soon enough to allow for the time to build it, though.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:29PM (#9371767)
You don't need to build any sort of permanent structure. Orbits exist.

Just coordinate trajectories. Throw a bunch of chaff at it from different trajectories, so that it passes through them in stages.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by Arcsech on Monday April 13, 2015 @06:53PM (#9371049)
Under certain circumstances, but since the mass can be (relatively) small due to the extremely high velocity, it can be very hard to spot.

Essentially, imagine trying to pick something the size of a telephone pole, angled end-on at you, from 20 miles away out of the entire night sky. By the time it gets close enough to spot easily, it's too late to do much about it.

Edit: jjaredsimpson's comment makes a very good point about velocities much closer to 1c. My comment mostly relates to the more immediately practical kinetic bombardment[0], which works on the same idea.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by jjaredsimpson on Monday April 13, 2015 @06:53PM (#9371054)
If I accelerate 1000 1kg masses to .99c 1ly away from your planet you can't detect them, and I've just destroyed your entire species (sterilized the planet) with a metric ton of rocks.

It doesn't matter how long I take to accelerate them, once they are going fast you are destroyed in 1 year.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by rwallace on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:36PM (#9371406)
With the caveat that at the tech level required to launch such an attack, destruction of one's home planet would constitute something closer to vandalism of a historic site than destruction of one's species.

Of course, if you're thinking of a scenario where aliens at that tech level launch such an attack against us 21st-century humans, yes, we'd be toast.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:51PM (#9371858)
Why are you saying we couldn't detect them? There's enough interstellar medium to make any such impactor detectable.

(Rough calculation: 67kw/m^2. And that's not even talking about dust grains (which ends up with much brighter instantaneous flashes))

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by letstryagain on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:41PM (#9371985)
By the time you see it, it will be too late to respond.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Monday April 13, 2015 @11:53PM (#9372014)
Why?

Sure, there's time dilation effects, but they are largely cancelled out. We have less notice for a given distance, but we also can see it coming from farther away.

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by InclinedPlane on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:05AM (#9372040)
.99c means that you have 1/100th as much time to respond relative to the detection distance. Let's say you spot the impactors an entire light-year away. The light will only reach you less than 4 days before impact. Can you put together an effective response plan in 4 days? If instead you spotted them out in the oort cloud (say, 1000 AU away) you would have less than 2 hours to respond.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:47AM (#9374166)
Right, but that is compensated by the fact that that same time compression also applies to any energy released by the impactor. It'd be putting out >3.5*10^7 watts / m^2 at 0.99c, from our perspective. And a single sand grain hitting it would release 27GJ.

Not to mention... How on earth are you managing to keep something together when its being bombarded by hydrogen / helium at 0.99c?

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by deeviant on Monday April 13, 2015 @07:12PM (#9371116)
You would need some pretty killer orbital prediction to do this. I would assume you'd start a bit closer.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by EarthLaunch on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:08PM (#9371679)
A more interesting idea would be accelerating someone to the point where they meet the end of the universe.
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by ringshall on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:09AM (#9372049)
Carl Sagan discussed this in episode 8 of Cosmos. This segment of video[1] progresses from Leonardo DaVinci's flying machines to a relativistic space craft in about 7 minutes.

A spacecraft accelerating at 1 g, closer and closer to c, accelerating halfway and decelerating halfway, could travel to Barnard's Star in 8 years ship time; center of the Milky Way Galaxy in 21 years ship time, the Andromeda galaxy in 28 years ship time.

"In principle such a journey, mounting the decimal points closer and closer to the speed of light, would even permit us to circumnavigate the known universe in 56 years ship time. We would return tens of billions of years in the far future, with the Earth a charred cinder, and the Sun, dead. Relativistic space flight makes the universe accessible to advanced civilizations, but only to those who go on the journey, not to those who stay home."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abp3q7aYOss&feature=youtu.be...

Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by compsciphd on Monday April 13, 2015 @03:12PM (#9369731)
federation couldn't have used these against the Borg? might have saved picard a lot of trouble :)
Re:Relativistic kill vehicle by delecti on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:09PM (#9371325)
The Borg don't really stay stationed on planets, the Star Trek universe has FTL scanning technology, and as a general rule, physical projectiles are handwaved to be unable to penetrate shields on ships, and even if they didn't, that's exactly what the deflector is for.

Sorry you got downvoted though.