More recent thread:
http://lists.pfsense.org/pipermail/list/2015-April/008610.ht... http://lists.pfsense.org/pipermail/list/2015-April/008611.ht... http://lists.pfsense.org/pipermail/list/2015-April/008614.ht...
I'm a co-author on the mentioned paper, and the author of the second post. Edit: and author of the linked blog post above.
Re:Solaris adopting OpenBSD's pf
by PhantomGremlin on Sunday April 12, 2015 @10:46PM
(#9365719)
2.2 should prove to be significantly more scalable than OpenBSD, since we have SMP-capable pf now, which isn't doable in OpenBSD
I don't think Solaris needs very high performance (aka SMP-capable) pf.
People want SMP for pf because they want to push bytes thru a firewall. That sort of application probably isn't important for Solaris anymore. But that's just my conjecture, I don't really follow Solaris much nowadays.
So if ultimate performance isn't absolutely necessary, why not start with the original source, aka OpenBSD?
"2.2 should prove to be significantly more scalable than OpenBSD, since we have SMP-capable pf now, which isn't doable in OpenBSD (and will likely be a number of years until it is). Plus AES-NI, more coming soon. https://blog.pfsense.org/?p=1473
Bug fixes are brought over into FreeBSD from OpenBSD as needed (sometimes by us, sometimes by others), though FreeBSD pf is essentially a fork at this point since making it SMP-capable changed things significantly. It's mostly separately-maintained at this point."