News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by ux-app on Sunday April 12, 2015 @11:14AM (#9363592)
I thought I made my point quite easy to understand.

Unauthorized access to anyone's account is not a harmless prank! This goes double for accessing the teacher's account!!

These are the facts that I have been addressing. At no point have I introduced hypotheticals that did not occur. The student accessed the teacher's account by guessing or shoulder surfing for the PW. This is unacceptable and should in no way be treated as a "harmless prank".

Allowing this type of access does set a negative precedent which does open up a teacher to unnecessary risk!

I'm not sure if you are being deliberately obtuse in regard to this simple point.

This is a simple case of unauthorized computer access. In the adult world this is a criminal act. In the juvenile world the response should reflect the seriousness of the act. Your response seems to be "well.... kids will be kids and after all no harm was done". This is not how we educate ethical computer users.

let me again! resate what I have already said. I am not saying that the student should be punished for any potential trouble he could have caused. The act of gaining access to another person's account by nefarious (which includes simple guessing of the PW) means is itself a serious issue which warrants a serious response.

EDIT: From the article: "A student at a Tampa Bay-area middle school was charged with a felony cyber crime after gaining unauthorized access to a teacher's computer and changing the desktop photo."

from Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act

It seems rather cut and dried that under US law this teen was committing a federal crime by gaining unauthorized access to a school computer system (state school i'm guessing).

Now agree or disagree with the law, it is what it is. I categorically do not agree that this matter should have been made a police issue. This is an unnecessary escalation of matters in my opinion.

But your response of "harmless prank" is completely unreasonable and does not address the gravity of the situation.

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by jacquesm on Sunday April 12, 2015 @11:27AM (#9363632)
You're turning the whole thing upside-down. You make it as if the unauthorized access was the main theme here but in fact it was just a means-to-an-end in order to pull a harmless prank. Not unlike picking a lock to a classroom in order to make a drawing on the blackboard. Sure, picking locks is bad and in the adult world if you did it and you stole something behind the locked door you would be in real trouble.

But for a 17 year old that's just another lightly taken obstacle and for someone in education it is rather surprising that you can't make that leap. It wasn't about the access, it was all about the prank.

That the unauthorized access might be a bigger deal than the prank most likely did not enter into the mind of the kid and that's where the role of an educator would come in handy, but none seemed to have been present here.

FWIW when I was that age I 'hacked' the school time administration so I could get more computer time (which was limited at something ridiculously low). If I did that today I'd probably go to jail or something like that, whereas the opposite happened to me, the guy that administered the system figured out that I knew the machine (a 'Prime') better than he did and asked me to plug the holes in the time administration system instead.

And that was arguably a much more serious offence than what this kid did.

Anyway, since you're assuming I'm being deliberately obtuse I'll bow out of the conversation here. Thank you for the exchange.

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by ux-app on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:28PM (#9364065)

   > Anyway, since you're assuming I'm being deliberately obtuse I'll bow out of the conversation here. Thank you for the exchange.
   
If this offended you then I apologise. Since the beginning of this thread I have been arguing for a reasonable middle ground between

   - shrugging shoulders and saying "harmless prank" and
   - felony charge. 
   
To me this is such a reasonable position to hold that it seemed that you were arguing for the sake of it :)

From your personal experience it's clear why you feel some solidarity with this student and helps me to understand your position better.

As a teacher, the possibility of having my account compromised by any student (malicious or otherwise) poses such a potentially dire threat to my livelihood that simply letting this transgression slide would not be a possibility.

As an educator, part of my duty is to prepare young people for the real world. Allowing unauthorised computer access to go unpunished is at odds with what society deems acceptable, particularly in the age of online banking etc. This kind of activity is criminal in the real world. Letting it slide in a school setting is teaching the wrong thing to our students, your own positive experience notwithstanding.

Just to clarify, punishment in a school setting is very flexible. For some students simply asking that they write a well reasoned apology is sufficient. For others, maybe repeat offenders, suspension or in extreme cases even expulsion is the correct response. Unlike adult punishment (prison), in a school setting the goal really is rehabilitation and personal growth. Contrary to many 14 year old's view we are not the enemy.

Pleasure chatting. All the best, Eli

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by zaroth on Sunday April 12, 2015 @05:30PM (#9364801)
Entering the conversation very late, but IMO the potential for catastrophic results puts the onus on the school system and teacher to secure the computer. Administration and IT is absolutely responsible for providing adequate and proportional investment into the security of the computer systems based on the level of risk involved from a compromise. The required level of protection is commensurate with the risk. This is standard operating procedure for any kind of security assessment and deployment, whether it be physical or electronic security. The school system and teacher were both grossly negligent in protecting the computer system, and for example, in the case of a data breach (if the standardized state tests that were on the machine were stolen) I believe the school system and the teacher would both be partial liable for improperly securing the device.

When an actual crime occurs, the punishment for the act should be proportional to the actual act. Not the potential for someone else with the same level of access to have done worse. E.g. Someone breaks into a house to steal a loaf of bread because they are starving. There were children sleeping in the house who could have hypothetically been kidnapped. We don't (or at least, shouldn't!) charge the bread burglar with attempted kidnapping or worse because children happened to be present but slept through the entire event.

The potential for worse is a clear signal that the school system and the teacher are not doing enough to protect these devices. The problem here isn't the child changing the background image, it's the lax security of the computer systems. Stringing up the child for changing a desktop background is what's missing the forest for the trees. Seriously, thank the child for exposing a clear operational weakness in security controls, fire the current IT department head, and get someone competent to secure the systems.

When a criminal act results in actual follow-on damages, then it is appropriate to charge the instigator. If our hypothetical bread burglar broke the lock, stole the bread, and then someone else came in through the open door and kidnapped the children, then absolutely the bread burglar will be charged as an accessory to kidnapping. But there's a clear line, you cannot stray into the hypothetical otherwise, there is literally no limit to the hypothetical damage which can be caused by any otherwise inconsequential act.

E.g. Jaywalking could hypothetically cause a 10 car pile-up with major fatalities, but we don't charge jaywalkers with attempted manslaughter or even reckless endangerment unless there are specific confounding factors -- in almost all cases jaywalking remains a misdemeanor. What this kid did was exactly the jaywalking of "exceeding authorized access".

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by ux-app on Sunday April 12, 2015 @07:48PM (#9365188)
Thanks for the response. It seems though, that you haven't really read what I wrote throughout this entire thread.

I have always agreed that the password policy was very poor/negligent and that the school should do better in this regard.

I have never argued that the student should be punished for all potential havoc he could have wreaked. I stated this multiple times throughout the thread!

Once again i'll try to make my argument as simple and clear as possible:

1. The potential for harm when a student takes surreptitious control over a teacher's computer is high

2. It therefore follows that a student actively working to take control (via keylogger or by observing the typed pw) is itself a serious issue.

The changing of the desktop background is irrelevant. The unauthorized use of a computer is the main issue from the perspective of the school.

The previous commenter with whom I was discussing implied that the actions were a "harmless prank" and reading between the lines implied that the punishment should have been a cheerful ruffling of his hair and saying with a mock voice "now that was a bit naughty wasn't it Johnny? Lets not do that again! hahaha what a silly pranker you are!"

The article stated that the student will be facing felony charges.

My position is that the actions sat somewhere in the middle of these 2 extremes! Simply accessing a teacher's computer is a serous enough action that the student should suffer some type of reasonable school-based punishment. In my previous post i outlined that these can wildly range in severity from a simple letter right through to expulsion if dealing with a recidivist.

It really is hard for me to understand the confusion here.

and once again. I'm not defending the school's use of insecure passwords. I'm saying that regardless of their poor choice, a student who is actively working to undermine a teacher's account should face a fair and reasonable punishment that is more than a slap on the wrist and less than a felony charge.

I really can't make it clearer than this I think.

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by zaroth on Monday April 13, 2015 @01:09PM (#9368897)
I think I do understand your argument, I just follow your first statement, which I fully accept, with a different conclusion. From potential harm we should not treat an otherwise inconsequential act more seriously. From the potential harm we should plan appropriately and make commensurate investments in proper security.

I absolutely agree, that a student (or anyone) could gain unauthorized access to the computer / network is the primary concern. The fault there lies not with the student, but with the computer / network security. What the student in this case did was effectively provide free pen-testing. They exposed a serious security weakness in the system, and the school should basically thank them for it, and get to work fixing the system.

The severity of the crime should rest solely on the intent of the criminal and the extent of damage caused. Isn't that the baseline of our moral code? The flip side is deterrence. My point is we don't actually want to deter students pulling harmless pranks which expose serious security weaknesses.

This is a feature, not a bug, and the school should be quietly giving the kid detention while they get their own act together before a more serious breach occurs. Have they even changed passwords for the teachers? Nay, they are likely going to consider possibly working on that one maybe next year.

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by ux-app on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:35PM (#9371798)
I agree with almost everything you've said :)

   > I absolutely agree, that a student (or anyone) could gain unauthorized access to the computer / network is the primary concern. The fault there lies not with the student, but with the computer / network security.
This is incorrect and your reasoning here is faulty. It is diametrically opposed to how the community at large views this issue. If we treat children in this way, and then when the clock strikes 12 and they turn 18 they are suddenly treated in the exact opposite way!! A 180 degree flip. According to your logic, within in the school setting its a harmless prank and the blame squarely lies with the school. However, turn 18 and perform the exact same actions (simple intrusion) on an corporate server. Guess where the (legal) blame will lie??

I took issue with comments that the actions were a harmless prank. As adults, and particularly as teachers our duty is to help shape the next generation of ethical citizenry. Laughing this incident off and applying a token punishment would send the wrong message.

In many jurisdictions unauthorized computer access is a crime. If a student gained access to a NSA computer, do you think law enforcement would treat it as a harmless prank? Even if no data was destroyed or tampered with. The act of intrusion is itself a serious matter.

The school has a duty to use this as an opportunity to

1. Update their network security (obviously!)

2. Educate students that they can end up in prison (even as minors!) if they break into the wrong computer network.

This doesn't mean applying an out of proportion punishment to this student in order to make an example of him. This means applying a fair and proportionate response which, and i'' say it again... sits between the 2 extremes of "harmless prank" and felony offense.

The issue I've had all along is with brushing this away as harmless. Unlawful intrusion is a crime. As teachers we would do a poor job preparing our students for the real world by treating it, within the school setting, as a "harmless prank"

A harmless prank is throwing a water balloon at someone. Breaking and entering (digital or otherwise) is not in this category.

In addition, the law does not treat the flimsiness of the lock as a mitigating circumstance. You can protect your physical property with a $2 lock and, in the eyes of the law anyone circumventing this would be guilty of break and enter, in the same way as if they broke into a far more fortified premises.

laughing away the student's actions as a "harmless prank" would be to miss a valuable learning opportunity for everyone involved!

   > What the student in this case did was effectively provide free pen-testing
This was not a noble white-hat! If the student found an exploit and then went straight to the teacher to inform them, do you think this would have ever made front page news? The student had a history of "free pen testing", and they used this particular exploit to attempt malicious access and tampering of a teacher's machine.

Imagine if you did the same at your workplace. "Hey boss I have a habit of stealing coworker passwords. Dont worry though, it's just a harmless prank! HAHA"

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by zaroth on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @03:28AM (#9372629)
Your hypothetical of 'what if this happened in the workplace' is a good one. If someone changed their coworker's or manager's background image and ended up getting charged with a felony, I would be equally outraged.

Even as grounds for firing it's a stretch, although I suppose the specific content of the image could rise to sexual harassment which could make it more serious -- but that would be based on the coworker's response, and a greater pattern of behavior.

If they had to guess a coworker's password in order to do it, then the further reprimand goes to the coworker for having such an insecure password, but the original act of changing the background image is dealt with all the same, namely, a) laughing about it, b) laughing and then saying 'don't do that', or c) an internal reprimand. Under almost no circumstance could I imagine involving the police in any capacity for changing a coworker's background image.

In the workplace, again, the far-worse offense is actually the coworker losing control of their password. If an employee came to me complaining their background image was changed to two men kissing, on a machine with proprietary business documents (aka state standardize tests) on it, my first questions would be, not who did it, but where did you leave your machine unlocked and how did someone else gain access?

A felony conviction has lasting impact for decades, not to mention the act of prosecuting costs taxpayers thousands of dollars, and a waste of public resources. But even short of a felony charge, IMO it's simply not in the interest of anyone for accessing a computer to change a background image to be anything but an internal / administrative matter.

But I shouldn't have to venture into the hypothetical, and dramatically change the scenario to make the point, because in fact kids aren't treated the same as adults, and yes, when the clock strikes 12 and a child becomes an adult under the law, their responsibility and their relationship with the state is fundamentally altered. So the fact this is a child does make the charge even more outrageous.

I just fundamentally believe that the police and our criminal justice system are a form of violence to be wielded against the people only in times of absolute need and even then only in the minimum necessary and proportionate response. Changing a background image, to me, is an order of magnitude lower on the violence scale than any police intervention.

Re:Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Deskt... by ux-app on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @05:33AM (#9373055)
please don't take this as a critical or snarky comment (I've enjoyed our discussion), but did you read my responses in this thread?

   --- Since my very first comment in this thread I have said that the felony charge is a gross overreaction. ---
I've hilighted this so that we don't go off on a tangent again. The felony charge was wrong. However, In my view it was more than a "harmless prank". Labelling it as such is to do a disservice to the student who would gain a valuable education in the matter if dealt with in an appropriate manner.

The background image in this case is a red herring. It has nothing to do with the felony charges. The felony charges stem from unauthorized computer access.

If you'd like to read more about the particular law applicable then please visit:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act

   >  the further reprimand goes to the coworker for having such an insecure password, but the original act of changing the background image
   
Once again you have been tricked by the click-bait nature of the original article title. The background image change is irrelevant and had nothing to do with the felony aspect of the case.

In a workplace there is an implicit social contract in place between all workers. As an employee I should be able to go about my business without fear that my fellow workers are actively trying to undermine my network access. This is computer ethics 101. Anyone keylogging, bruteforcing or even simply guessing a coworkers password and then using this to gain access to their account is breaking this important social contract. This breeds distrust and is toxic to a work environment. As a first offence it's possible that you might get off with a stern warning and probation. A repeat offender, in any competent workplace would be summarily dismissed. This is without a doubt breach of contract. If you feel differently then I'd encourage you to read your own workplace contract. Or if you have a large enough workplace why not ask a manager what their take on the matter of taking surreptitious control of a co-workers machine via ill-gotten credentials. I don't think they'd have as relaxed a view as you seem to have.

Rather than using hypotheticals. I'll use an actual example from my own work experience. The following scenario occurs at least 4-5 times a month to me personally.

As a teacher I am moving from room, to room and logging into various computers throughout the day. It is not uncommon for a colleague of mine to be busy in a lesson, and once the screen saver has turned off their screen they forget to log off their machine. I come in, move the mouse, and see that another user is logged in. I'd like to think that I have a strong moral compass. My action, every time without exception is to immediately log them off. I even go so far as to not let my eyes wander about their desktop. The files and shortcuts they have there could potentially be sensitive and I personally believe that even taking undue note of the filenames would be a minor breach of their privacy.

   > my first questions would be, not who did it, but where did you leave your machine unlocked and how did someone else gain access?
I'd be very surprised if this was truly your first and most pressing concern. It would exhibit a poor understanding of computer security and the wider workplace context.

As anyone with even a basic IT background would know. If another party has physical access to your machine (as all co-workers do as a normal side effect of their employment) then security wise all bets are off. If a worker at a company displayed such bad judgement as to actively seek out to find and then use another person's credentials then they have exhibited a gross incompetence and should be dealt with accordingly. This is why a breach of the implicit social contract which states that my co-workers will not attempt to compromise my IT credentials is so vital. In cynical, purely business terms, a breakdown of this fundamental trust would breed mistrust and eventually affect morale and the bottom line.

   > In the workplace, again, the far-worse offense is actually the coworker losing control of their password
No. A truly nefarious employee could simply attach a tiny USB to the back panel (or even inside the case) of your machine which would keylog it. Even a password with 100bits of entropy would not mitigate against this attack. Strong passwords are important of course, but an employee who is actively seeking out to compromise their colleague's credentials is, in the extreme case, a possibly existential threat to the company. Vigorously weeding out any employees with a moral and ethical compass so skewed that they would even consider using another's credentials would be the immediate concern of any competent management team.

   > Changing a background image, to me, is an order of magnitude lower on the violence scale than any police intervention.
   
Once again you have been misled by clickbait. The background change is immaterial.

   > I just fundamentally believe that the police and our criminal justice system are a form of violence to be wielded against the people only in times of absolute need and even then only in the minimum necessary and proportionate response.
   
As stated many times already, I 100% agree with you. In the case of a teenager involving the police is a gross overreaction.

Labeling the offense of gaining unathorized access to a computer as a "harmless prank" is actively harmful. It portrays the act as without consequence, whereas in the real world it is anything but. In the real world doing this might get you fired or put in prison! A school's duty is to treat the offence with the gravity it deserves.