Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by joefreeman on Sunday April 12, 2015 @08:45AM
(#9363141)
I understand that notifications could be helpful in some cases, but I actually like the fact that people don't get notified when someone replies to their comment, and I had assumed this was deliberate. It seems to make debates more objective. For example, if user A makes a statement, and then B disagrees, I like the fact that C can come along and backup A's points, rather than a defensive response from A. (Having notifications that were delayed by an hour or so might make for a good middle ground.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by brudgers on Sunday April 12, 2015 @11:16AM
(#9363596)
My understanding is that it, no automatic notification of replies, is deliberate and the reason is to avoid stimulating flame wars. As someone who posts a lot and usually tries to avoid flame wars, the first thing I do on any site is turn off email notifications. If I care, I look at the threading of my comments.
Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by krapp on Sunday April 12, 2015 @08:47PM
(#9365348)
Preventing 'flame wars' by making conversations more awkward and difficult to follow as time goes on just seems to create friction for everyone. And it doesn't prevent flame wars - people who are emotionally invested in an argument will follow a thread on their own accord. We've all seen them, i'm kind of ashamed to say i've participated in a few.
But, notifications could be opt in by default and opt out by choice, and they wouldn't necessarily have to be by email - you could be shown the last few replies to your comments in your account.
Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by qu4z-2 on Monday April 13, 2015 @12:01AM
(#9365894)
Just to clarify terms here, "opt-in" means disabled by default, with user action needed to enable the feature. "opt-out" means on-by-default with the ability to disable it: exactly the situation you describe. At least, that's my understanding.
Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by krapp on Monday April 13, 2015 @12:14AM
(#9365930)
I may have misstated, then.. I meant that by default, you wouldn't get any notifications unless you chose to, and if you did, you could turn them off at any time.
Re:Remind HN: Followups are impossible if you have no contac...
by swsieber on Sunday April 12, 2015 @04:45PM
(#9364684)
A longer delay would also be fine. Perhaps after a certain amount of time notifications could be turned on - say 5 days after a post + 1 hour delay? That seems to be in line with the OP, but I'm not sure.