News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by davidw on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:55PM (#936207)
You will be very surprised to hear my suggestion: kill the off-topic articles mercilessly. No politics/economics and no fluff.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jacquesm on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:35PM (#936319)
Right now an article about veterans is the #3 post on the homepage and has an enormous number of points.

Good luck with that.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by pg on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:32PM (#936623)
I figure it's ok to leave up the occasional commemorative post, when it's by an old and respected member of the community, so I didn't kill it. I think I'm going to have to though; the comments show HN users can't be trusted with this topic.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2009 @02:41AM (#937341)
That's a very slippery slope, 'old and respected' should not matter when posting off-topic stuff.

I've seen content that was much more on-topic killed off ruthlessly, it creates a sense of class-justice.

Whoever posted it and how long they have been a member should not be the deciding factor in killing stuff or letting it be.

Anyway, of course it is your call, but that's how I feel about it.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by davidw on Thursday November 12, 2009 @01:40AM (#937274)
I think the problem is that there are very few 'hops' between "trusted, respected person writes something intelligent" and "flame wars" when the topic is emotionally loaded/political/economics/etc... Fluff articles aren't quite so bad, but I think they still beget more fluff.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by davidw on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:41PM (#936342)
I liked raganwald's post, agreed with it, and think that he's generally a very bright and interesting guy, but I still flagged the article since I thought it wasn't really hacker news. pg can just up and kill stuff though, and doing more of that would set the tenor of the site.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jacquesm on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:53PM (#936374)
So, that makes two flags, it's still there. Similar sentiment on the flag by the way, it's a good thing he did but I feel it does not belong here.

I've been wondering for a while now if this flagging is useful or not, it doesn't seem to have too much effect, if any.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by scott_s on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @05:18PM (#936442)
If I recall correctly, pg made an addition that if a submission has over X points, it won't be auto-killed by flagging.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2009 @03:21AM (#937378)
Correct, but that means that an editor will look at it (as happened, see above) and has to decide whether to give the article a pass or not.

I wasn't referring to the 'auto kills', but to the editor kills.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Confusion on Thursday November 12, 2009 @02:58AM (#937359)
I wanted to flag it for the same reason, but there wasn't a 'flag' link anymore...
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by tomjen2 on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:55PM (#936379)
I flagged that article, but I guess I don't have enough karma for it to matter yet.

I properly also triggered the spam filter, because I just went to the thread and downvoted all the comments.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2009 @06:17AM (#937540)
> I just went to the thread and downvoted all the comments.

Now why on earth would you do that ?

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jodrellblank on Thursday November 12, 2009 @11:11AM (#937993)
Not surprised, and agree. HN isn't covering a nice natural boundary of topics, it's trying to fit a group of people's ideas for interesting topics.

If and when it isn't doing that, said group of people should prune away the topics they don't want - otherwise it will grow into a general discussion site. Like pruning a shrub or guiding a vine. Yes, it's a bit dictatorial and a bit undemocratic, and that's fine because it's not a popularity contest trying to target the majority of people.

Often when googling for a problem and finding a result, there's a languishing forum post that goes

"problem" "irrelevant suggestion" "irrelevant suggestion" "unhelpful but well meaning comment" "me too" "answer"

and I wish someone had enough care to weed out the drivel.