Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by ageek123 on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:08PM
(#9361359)
So you are arguing that someone in the 39.6% tax bracket gets 164% more "in return for the taxes they pay" than someone in the 15% tax bracket? (Or infinitely more than someone who pays no income tax at all?)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by Spooky23 on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:21PM
(#9361419)
Sure. The people getting taxed at 39.6% of income over net income over $430k are almost certainly in some sort of business, whose profitability almost certainly depends on the prosperity of the 99.5% of Americans making less money.
Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by ageek123 on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:31PM
(#9361453)
That argument is absurd. It's like saying that an employee has some kind of moral obligation to their employer because without the employer, they wouldn't have a job. The reality is that in a market economy, people voluntarily exchange goods, services, labor, whatever, when the exchange is mutually beneficial. Nobody owes anyone anything in the sense you are talking about.
Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by sudioStudio64 on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:45PM
(#9361496)
I'm not trying to be offensive, but that simplifies the human condition to an almost cartoon-ish degree. People aren't really the simple rational economic actors that are useful in theory. I know that sounds trite, but it is true.
Now I'm not a supporter of calling taxes a good thing - they are violent theft after all - but for better or worse those 39.6%ers would have had 164% less of anything without the taxes in the first place.
No society on the planet has organized without violent taxation, and there is no way those less fortunate could foot more of the bill. You can of course argue about reducing that bill - I am all for it - but arguing that the affluent are not benefiting their share from taxes is insane - they are only wealthy because those taxes exist.
Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by argumentum on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:34PM
(#9361466)
Depends how you look at it. If it's a "survival of the fittest" state of nature, which is what humans emerged from, remember that those with a lot have a lot to lose, those with nothing have nothing to lose. We'd either fight it out, or come to an understanding about how to share limited resources while cooperating for the betterment of all.
This is the social contract, google and wikipedia are your friends ;)
Re:Top 20% of Earners Pay 84% of Income Tax
by clusterbits on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:14PM
(#9361380)
IMHO everybody has to contribute as much as he can. That's the only way a society can survive.