News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BuzzFeed denies deleting critical articles to appease adv... by danso on Saturday April 11, 2015 @04:44PM (#9360755)
I'm a frequent defender of BuzzFeed as a legit news source...they've hired several colleagues and friends of mine and there are multiple Pulitzer winners among their large data/investigations team.

But this latest incident is pretty disturbing...I would've figured that BuzzFeed's clout (and funding) was so high that annoying a couple of advertisers with articles was a cost of doing business that could easily be swallowed, rather than compromise their integrity.

But as the famous Watergate saying goes, it's not the crime, it's the coverup. Not only were the deletions done secretly, but when exposed, the excuses were so transparently lame. The post critical of Dove was deleted because it was a "hot take", and deleting it was necessary to get the point across to the writers? That's an editorial-style kerfluffle, one that could be explained through a memo, not _retracting the article_. Keep in mind that a retraction is traditionally done for very serious screwups, like the time Rolling Stone accused UVA of covering up a gang-rape but didn't interview anybody involved. Making a low-quality post should not be grounds for deletion.

And this became a lot worse when the Hasbro/Monopoly article was discovered...when the Dove post was deleted, BuzzFeed's editor said that was the first and only time such a deletion had been done...the Monopoly post was deleted a month or so ago. And the lame reason for that deletion was that the post was too opinionated, and that it too was a one-time-action.

Kind of strange that of the thousands of posts BuzzFeed makes in a single week, the only two that of such egregious quality that they were completely deleted (and done so in such a way as to be removed from the Internet Archive and Google Cache) had to do with two prominent advertisers.

I know publishing is a business, and all journalism institutions make various compromises/cutbacks for bottom-line reasons. But the cover-up here is more egregious than most.

Re:BuzzFeed denies deleting critical articles to appease adv... by foobarqux on Saturday April 11, 2015 @07:44PM (#9361280)
The only difference with old-media is that there they kill the story before it is ever published.
Re:BuzzFeed denies deleting critical articles to appease adv... by siegecraft on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:02PM (#9361749)
I'm sure old-media would love to be able to kill a story after it's published, they just didn't have the tech.
Re:BuzzFeed denies deleting critical articles to appease adv... by anon1385 on Sunday April 12, 2015 @03:33AM (#9362517)
They can and do still remove stories from their websites: https://www.opendemocracy.net/ourkingdom/peter-oborne/why-i-...

>I researched the newspaper’s coverage of HSBC. I learnt that Harry Wilson, the admirable banking correspondent of the Telegraph, had published an online story about HSBC based on a report from a Hong Kong analyst who had claimed there was a ‘black hole’ in the HSBC accounts. This story was swiftly removed from the Telegraph website, even though there were no legal problems. When I asked HSBC whether the bank had complained about Wilson's article, or played any role in the decision to remove it, the bank declined to comment. Mr Wilson’s contemporaneous tweets referring to the story can be found here. The story itself, however, is no longer available on the website, as anybody trying to follow through the link can discover. Mr Wilson rather bravely raised this issue publicly at the ‘town hall meeting’ when Jason Seiken introduced himself to staff. He has since left the paper.

Most reputable papers wouldn't do this with a new piece though. Opinion pieces seem to get removed at times, mainly when there is a backlash and the paper feels that a column crossed the line from controversial clickbait into something that's drawing too much heat (e.g. http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2013/01/14/observer-editor-john-mu... ).