I would be ok if Linux became the open source windows flavored OS and Freebsd became the open source unix flavored OS.
This mindset should terrify everyone in the GNU foundation. systemd is the begining of the march away from both the GNU and GPL principles, into an incompatible fork of POSIX that uses RPC backdoors in order to circumvent GPL protections.why doesn't anyone else view systemd as the direct assault on GNU that it is?
The answer will come quickly, I bet. it's how you figure out magic tricks, as well. :)
> Systemd is much more a "Windows" approach to system
> configuration management
I can't see your Windows analogy. The Windows init system compares badly to everything in play here - it doesn't make the system observable or discoverable or give power to the user or do a good job of centralising control.There would be a comparison to Mac OSX, which has rounded the corners of init with its own approach.
It's also worth mentioning that all mainstream unix (even OpenBSD) deviates from unix philosophy in places. A trivial example - the way that /bin/ls changes behaviour depending on whether it's outputting to stdout or to pipe. If there's a gold standard, it's Plan 9. And almost nobody uses that.
theres some discussion here though: https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/systemd-vs-launchd.44973/
(I'm just commenting to make sure people know that OSX's init system is not exactly without major criticism from people who know there stuff)
Seriously, it does not make any sense to say that systemd is a "Windows" approach.
How this isn't worse than Tivo-ization (the reason the GPLv3 was written!), now how RMS/Moglen aren't screaming about this, I'll never know.
Spawning processes and communicating over pipes is a UNIX tradition and also lets you sidestep the GPL. Should RMS be screaming about that too?
Maybe you can explain what a "derivative work" means to you, in relation to the GPL?
I keep coming back to that. It seems to me that there is a tension in the Linux world about people who want an open source UNIX and people who want an open source Windows. Systemd is much more a "Windows" approach to system configuration management than a "UNIX" approach.
That isn't "bad" per se but it makes for some confusing things. I would be ok if Linux became the open source windows flavored OS and Freebsd became the open source unix flavored OS. I believe such an explicit step would help folks move forward with "where" a certain idiom of OS management should land in the open source world. Of course I don't expect that to happen :-).