News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by wglb on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @02:44PM (#935991)
How about this small thing--change the wording of the button add comment to add thoughtful comment.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by hxa7241 on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:11PM (#936094)
Some research (probably see Cialdini) shows significantly improved compliance when a question is asked that requires confirmation from the subject. So it would better as: "Will you add a thoughtful comment?". How that can be best realised in a web context is something for further consideration . . .
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by amichail on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @05:01PM (#936399)
Here's something that is more likely to work: PG gets more voting power than anyone else. Moreover, his voting gives/takes away voting power to/from submitters/commenters, and their voting do likewise, and so on.

In this way, ultimately PG determines the character of the site by spreading voting power directly and indirectly via his voting.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by NathanKP on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @05:35PM (#936492)
That wouldn't necessarily work because the next person below PG would be likely to be more willing to upvote someone who wasn't as focused. They in turn would be willing to upvote someone else who was worse and so on.

I think it makes more sense for voting power to be associated with karma level.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jjs on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:28PM (#937025)
> I think it makes more sense for voting power to be associated with karma level.

This could be gamed, or lead to runaway karma effects within a small, incestuous cabal.

If I were pg, I would handle it similarly to amichail's suggestion, but instead of voting power going to submitters of articles that I like, I would have it go to voters of articles that I like.

In other words, I would restate the problem as, "I can't be awake 24 hours to moderate every single submission, so instead, I'll assign invisible voting power based on how reliably a given voter's running and recent preferences match what I would want to see on the front page."

I would add some random jitter to the algorithm, to mildly penalize people whose votes are too similar to my own.

The bonus to consistently good submitters would not be better voting privileges, but better submitting privileges (better initial placement and/or slower decay).

And I would silently give voters and submitters whose patterns negatively correlated with my preferences corresponding penalties, and use their poor taste as valuable data on what not to put on the front page.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Readmore on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @05:34PM (#936486)
I don't know, that sounds like a Monarchy to me.

If you wanted to go that way why not make a user's 'voting power' be based on their own karma / time on the site. This rewards users who have been around longer and have been 'peer reviewed' through their karma.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by endtime on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:07PM (#937006)
I'm not sure this is evolutionarily stable against an invasion of new users multiple times the size of the original population.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by riffer on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @05:40PM (#936504)
This would be like non-binary whitelists that have multiple levels. I like it.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by dhimes on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:52PM (#937059)
I would love to see if this works.

"Feel free to enhance the discussion" or "Feel free to add value to this thread"

Any other ways to word it worth considering?

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by blasdel on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @08:31PM (#936862)
The comment fields on the MetaFilter sites have little admonishments underneath them:

http://www.metafilter.com | Note: Help maintain a healthy, respectful discussion by focusing comments on the issues, topics, and facts at hand—not at other members of the site.

http://ask.metafilter.com | Note: Ask MetaFilter is as useful as you make it. Please limit comments to answers or help in finding an answer. Wisecracks don't help people find answers. Thanks.

http://metatalk.metafilter.com | Note: Everyone needs a hug.

In the old days comments always had to be previewed in context (with a full refresh) before they could be posted. The "New Post" pages have huge search fields for dupe avoidance, dupe search on preview, stern warnings about what is allowed, and occasionally a row of siren.gif from the Drudge Report.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by kirubakaran on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:15PM (#936109)
Yes, this simple change could really work much better than all the fancy solutions. This is a social solution to a social problem.

I would suggest one additional thing, which is a little bit more invasive. After a user submits a comment, show a confirmation question like "Are you sure you are making a positive contribution to the conversation? [Yes] [No]"

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by lucumo on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:12PM (#936247)
I'm afraid that won't work for long. People will read it once and then comply. Maybe the second and third time they'll stop to think about it for a few seconds, but after that it'll get enshrined in muscle memory, without people actually reading the statement, let alone think about it.

I believe the posts are only part of the problem, though. The post obviously needs to exist, but it's the votes that make a comment insipid or insidious. Votes are multipliers: nobody cares about a stupid comment with few upvotes and a great comment with many upvotes is an even greater comment. It's when the votes are distributed the other way around that problems start.

Furthermore, a poster that gets downvoted will probably learn from the experience whereas if he gets upvoted, he's encouraged.

The problem and the solution therefore probably lie in the voting system. There's a few options I can think of right now:

* Giving high-karma individuals more voting power. Maybe tiered or maybe on an analogue scale. This has the problem that not all karma as it is now is deserved. (Take mine: I seem to get most upvotes for snide remarks and snarky questions, not for the posts where I want to make a point.) That said, karma probably still is an indicator of quality of posts, so it may work.

* Make upvoting cost a bit of karma. I don't think this will work well, since you'll end up with a closed economy where only the top X% of the users can really participate. And X will be decreasing when more players come in.

* Give a certain amount of points each day to spend on votes. (I'm not a user of that site, but I believe Slashdot uses it. Is that correct?) This will make upvotes a scarce resource, making people be more careful what they upvote. Of course, if unused points get deleted at the end of the day, people may try to spend unused points on things they wouldn't normally upvote.

* Up the current karma-limits. Right now you need X karma for feature Y, but with the influx of new users, karma has inflated somewhat. It's much easier to get to X if 10 people read your posts than it would be if only 1 person read it.

Just a few things of the top of my head. I'm not the smartest guy here, so it may not be a whole lot, though...

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by kirubakaran on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:24PM (#936282)
Great points.

"I'm not the smartest guy here, so it may not be a whole lot, though..."

Please don't ever think that. 'Smartness' is just a function of few things which are in your control, at least in the long run. Thinking "I am not smart" is self-fulfilling.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by tptacek on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:51PM (#936651)
High karma at the very least represents a stake in the site. Not every high-karma comment is worth anything, but virtually every high-karma user cares about the culture of HN.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by unalone on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:31PM (#937033)
True this. When I joined, I quickly found out that the people on the leaderboard tended to be the people whose names I remembered throughout threads.

I'd also place a bet that not too many people with lots of karma are flippant spammers; even the ones I think can be jerks sometimes (myself totally included) at least are putting in an effort.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by chasingsparks on Thursday November 12, 2009 @07:43PM (#939111)
I actually was going to start a new thread about making Karma a currency. Happily, I searched this thread first.

I would also add one item to the list. Make all comments cost Karma. If you are saying something that you do not think has the potential to be upvoted, just don't say it.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by pg on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:16PM (#936579)
Hmm. Could do this for new accounts at least.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by andrewljohnson on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:03PM (#936225)
This may be a dumb idea, but how about requiring some minimum length of comment? Are there circumstances when someone legitimately should just use 8-10 words? I don't know what that minimum length would be though.

At least in this case if people want to be strident or acerbic, they have to work for it.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by pg on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:19PM (#936593)
I've thought of considering comment length in the sorting algorithm. There's definitely a correlation between length and quality.

Another possibility would be to look at the words people used. I'm pretty sure you could train a spam filter to recognize lame comments.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Freebytes on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:48PM (#936648)
Another possibility would be to implement a waiting period before people have the opportunity to vote. This may help with the issue of newer members upvoting the one line witty comments. However, I am not sure if the short comments are necessarily negative. Should users be required to contribute exceptionally long and verbose posts without the benefit of shorter posts in between? From my own perspective, I tend to only skim over 'wall of text' comments if they do not engage my interests from the beginning so the intermingling of short comments with longer comments to me is not a bad thing. The voting up or down of comments from those that may be deemed inadequate to accurately judge the quality of the post (new members) seems to be more of an issue. These new users may vote based on their opinions (as I mentioned in another post) rather than on the quality of the arguments or information presented so a probation period may be the solution.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by prakash on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:19PM (#937017)
Another possibility would be to look at the words people used. I'm pretty sure you could train a spam filter to recognize lame comments.

I think you are onto something here.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Freebytes on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:58PM (#936672)
(I was going to include this as an edit to my previous post, but it really needs its own comment post.) I created a site with a Karma based system. The Karma was actually transferred from person to person, though. Everyone started with 0 Karma, and only the administrator could feed Karma into the system. The users could transfer to each other, but as they gave Karma they would lose Karma. A potential benefit is that the administrator can feed Karma into the system by rewarding people that contribute based on particular topics as chosen by the administrator. I am not sure if this would be a good idea for this site, but I am simply stating it to get the ideas flowing for other solutions. I really like the way the site operates even if there are potentials for abuse or inaccuracies.

Also, not related to the topic so much, I find it funny that I often see people say "I do not care about points." but are also the most likely people to make suggestions about new ways to implement the points system.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Retric on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @10:00PM (#937000)
Another option would be to have a hidden karma impact on sorting. Keeping a hidden score based on the log(karma) of the up voters might dilute the impact of people until they have been around for a while and help maintain the current culture without ignoring new opinions.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jodrellblank on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:27PM (#936290)
You advocate verbosity to the author of arc?
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jodrellblank on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:40PM (#936338)
I'm trying to make this a zingy one liner, because it wouldn't be such a good comeback unless it also fitted within the 8-10 words that the parent post was complaining about.

It is supposed to reference the idea that there isn't any intrinsic merit in verbosity, and that we often prize writing that is pared down and says only what it needs to - prose or code, and as a group prize languages that allow conciseness with joy going to Ruby, reverence to R and J, and fear and loathing to XML.

Particularly PG who has written more than once about Lisp and how it allows dense code to express a lot, so much so indeed that he reduced function creation to 'fn' in the language that backs this very site on which you are suggesting longer comments are the answer.

(See? Not so insightful, sharp and cool now, is it?)

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by mquander on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:32PM (#936624)
It's not as sharp and cool, but it's equally insightful, and it provides a lot more material with which to actually have a conversation, rather than just shoot back a counter-opinion.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by andrewljohnson on Thursday November 12, 2009 @04:49AM (#937437)
It's just this sort of zingy one-liner that hurts HN. You are playing into the cult of personality, your comment does little to further the discussion, and it's basically just an inside joke. Surprise, surprise... you have thirteen points at the time of this retort.

Instead, you should debate the merits of the idea. I was actually not so much advocating the idea as I was bringing it up for discussion - you can tell by the tone of my comment. And, while I questioned myself for even bringing up the idea of a length requirement, your response makes me lean a little bit more towards the idea.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jodrellblank on Thursday November 12, 2009 @10:37AM (#937907)
I am playing to the karma, which is one reason I advocate my suggestion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=936306 where people could agree with my zing yet still bury my comment as a bad contribution.

When voting, I vote up for "interesting point", for "you put a lot of effort into this reply" and for "I agree" and "ha!". I feel conflicted downvoting a comment I like even if it's not contributory, and I don't want to upvote a comment I disagree with even if it's a good contribution. Split the two up so the conflict goes away.

You are playing into the cult of personality

It's what the site's design encourages - usernames are prominent, vote scores are prominent and tallied as the main measure of a person, popular comments get votes. Big thoughtful comments and deep discussion get squashed into nesting and pushed aside by the ever increasing flood of new submissions. "Furthering the discussion" as you put it ... what does this mean to you? Who is supposed to benefit and how, and does the site design encourage that?

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by andrewljohnson on Thursday November 12, 2009 @03:03PM (#938606)
I think furthering the discussion in this case means talking about the pros and cons of adding a comment length requirement.

Since the site owner pg is in on this thread, the community may benefit by Paul getting some feedback and ideas on how to improve the site.

The site's design does encourage conversation of course. Comments are threaded to encourage back-and-forth, and voting moderation promotes good comments and helps to keep the discussion civil.

I too like to get some karma, but I'll sometimes write something that I suspect may be down-voted (or even that I may not believe) just because I like to discuss things. Karma doesn't really matter on this site or affect your experience (other than being able to down-vote comments), and I think that fact encourages people not to treat it very seriously.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by jonny_noog on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @06:11PM (#936571)
I think it would just end up with trolls pasting in Lorem Ipsum or something after their trollish comment. Having trash text in low quality comments might make them easier to identify as low quality and the need to post comments of a minimum length may possibly discourage some people from posting "zingers", but I don't feel it would be a net win overall.
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by Zak on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @08:44PM (#936887)
I don't think so. I think the vast majority of users will down-vote and/or flag comments intentionally padded with nonsense.

I'd like to see a more sophisticated quality detection system - a learning text classifier of some sort. PG might have enough experience in that field of programming to come up with something useful along those lines.

Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by kirubakaran on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:27PM (#936288)
Re:Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments? by tomjen2 on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:51PM (#936364)
The arcticle is blogspam. The right one is here.

Okay that took nine.