News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by mattmcknight on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @01:59PM (#935845)
Fix the damn language. It's a serious bug in written English, which is basically a garbled bag of idiotic spellings that were much more flexible applied. Now that someone has marked time with a dictionary...we assume that spelling is never allowed to change again. txtrs say no.
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by uhiubiv on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @02:10PM (#935876)
It's simple you use 's in "it's" ="it is" to mark the missing 'i' and you use the 's in eg. "the writer's article" to mark a missing 'e' from "writeres" the original possessive which disappeared sometime in late Saxon (6th century)

Although "its" is also possessive you don't use an apostrophe because that would confuse its with "it's"

Then if the word ends in an s the rules are different unless it's a name, then the rules are different again, unless it's a biblical name then the rules are different to the last rule, except for Moses and Jesus which are exceptions to this. Then of course there are always a few special cases - St James' park (footbal ground) but St James's park (park)

Of course if the word originally comes from another language then you have to use the rules from the language instead, well sometimes, say for French but not German or Dutch, actually only sometimes for Dutch depending.

Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by CWuestefeld on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:37PM (#936326)
People always want to write the third person possessive as "it's", presumably because they're thinking the "'s" is needed to indicate possession.

Why doesn't this mistake carry over to the gendered forms? That is, why don't people write "hi's" or "her's"?

Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by mdemare on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @02:02PM (#935854)
But you'll break backward compatibility. Also, there are too many different accents for any one-to-one mapping between spelling and pronunciation to work.
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by mattmcknight on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:51PM (#936192)
Not really. Did you ever read Shakespeare? Language and spelling are always changing. It works in many other languages as well, despite the existence of accents.
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by CWuestefeld on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:34PM (#936316)
Did you ever read Shakespeare?

Couldn't make heads or tails of his writing. Maybe because it's shifted so much in the intervening centuries that it's only marginally comprehensible to someone who learned the modern tongue?

How has Gutenberg changed the rate of change in languages? Has greater availability of printed materials held things steady longer?

How is the Intertubes changing this? Has the ability to instantly view the work of people representing a zillion languages accelerated change?

Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by algorias on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @02:52PM (#936026)
It's possible to build good communication on top of faulty protocols. Don't blame the language.

The value of the words in the dictionary stems from their widespread use. Intrinsically, they don't have any.

Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by mcantor on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @02:34PM (#935949)
Downvoted for feckless prescriptivism. :-(
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by mattmcknight on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:52PM (#936200)
Well, I am actually in favor of the opposite of prescriptivism, when the current prescription causes so many problems.
Re:Learn Your Damn Homophones by asciilifeform on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @03:05PM (#936068)
English isn't broken. It simply comes with a built-in IQ test.