Re:Ruling from USPTO Invalidates All Claims Used to Threaten...
by nileshtrivedi on Saturday April 11, 2015 @01:00AM
(#9358568)
Patents are an incentive to disclose the techniques behind inventions. Plenty of incentives already exist to create things and invest in R&D.
Re:Ruling from USPTO Invalidates All Claims Used to Threaten...
by tjl on Saturday April 11, 2015 @02:00AM
(#9358685)
My thought has been that they need to go back to requiring a physical implementation. So, if you devise a hardware product that includes software, the whole thing can be patented, but not the specific algorithms. This eliminates all the business process patents and basically software patents as well.
Re:Ruling from USPTO Invalidates All Claims Used to Threaten...
by jheriko on Monday April 13, 2015 @04:36PM
(#9370308)
I think a very large part of innovation comes from people who would do it anyway. Supporting them is great.
The current system is in everyone's worst interest. Getting there first shouldn't be worth as much as being able to provide an excellent quality of product or service - software or otherwise. You certainly shouldn't be able to hold up all of humanity's progress for the entire future because you can claim priority.
Re:Ruling from USPTO Invalidates All Claims Used to Threaten...
by spacemanmatt on Saturday April 11, 2015 @06:39AM
(#9359051)
Software is abstract. Abstract subjects are strictly ineligible.
Software is a different beast, simply because the vagueness you can express in a software patent can be so general that it covers use cases almost retroactively.
Software patents should be extremely specific, regular patents work for the most part.