They seem to have chosen to act as a free classified ad publisher and disclaim any responsibility for conflict resolution, but the business would be much more valuable if they could improve that.
On top of the listings, we also provide a full-fledged (MVP at this point) rental transaction process. So we are not just a free classifieds, but a marketplace/platform that tries to facilitate the entire ad-hoc rental transaction life cycle.
If anyone is interested, they can try out the rental process on the site themselves.
The strategies are traditional business practices like guarantees, insurance, and dispute resolution combined with technology to lower costs.
In this case, perhaps an app in which both the owner and renter agree when the item is loaned and returned, which reminds the renter to return the item, automatically tracks charges on overdue rentals, and allows some automated dispute resolution like: "I'm at the owner's address (GPS confirms it) and the owner isn't available."
Risk of course exists, hence the deposit and the rental price that the item owner collects upfront. Our site facilitates the rental transaction process by providing step-by-step guides and tools, such as pre-filled ready-to-use rental contract that the owner and renter can optionally choose to use - all they need to do is to sign and date. Also we provide Google Calendar export so that you can setup the pickup/return easily and invite the other party so that both sides don't forget. Once involved in a transaction, both sides can communicate using the private direct messaging without revealing email/phone numbers upfront.
The process can be enhanced and improved for sure along the way, but we'll have to build up some user base first
The question is how is it going to work with the $10/day power-tool. Let's say even if someone breaks my power-tool it will be reimbursed and I'm 100% sure - how much time/paper-work will this reimbursement take up?
And as you suggest, the site would need to make dispute resolution as simple as possible. Perhaps automatically refunding both sides for disputes, but banning users with too many disputes.
It's not simple--certainly not as simple as publishing free ads--but that's why a business that can do it is valuable.
It's not hard to loan someone a power-tool - but $10 just isn't worth the potential problems which go with it.