News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasons not to buy from Amazon by basseq on Friday April 10, 2015 @02:37PM (#9356257)
Barring a point-by-point analysis, his interesting points include:

- Non-ethical corporate compliance with surveillance activities.

- Pay-for-placement allegations. (Especially interesting given recent lawsuit for ratings spam.)

- Warehouse worker treatment.

- Monopolistic pricing power, particularly against small publishers. (Also ironic, as Amazon has given self-publishers a great platform.)

Note that this is just a list of allegations: this isn't a particularly investigative piece. (Though several have been linked and/or published elsewhere.)

Less valid arguments/rhetoric include:

- Calling the Kindle a Swindle. (Cute, but I can't take your argument as a serious, objective view.)

- Broad "freedom" arguments about file formats (PDF, MP3) and rights associated with same not originating with Amazon.

- Auto-update as a "back-door".

- Hosted content vs. owned content and the pros and cons therein.

- Workers "walk all day under the orders of a computer". (Like Uber drivers drive all day under the orders of a computer?)

- General competitiveness against bookstores and differences in business models.

So I'm saying that Stallman makes N interesting points (albeit without much in the way of reasoning), another N points I find to be logically unsound, and that combination of factors lead to an overall "article" that isn't very impactful.

The interesting points are still interesting.

There are no comments on this comment yet.