News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by omgitstom on Friday April 10, 2015 @11:09AM (#9354822)
How do you stop the mass surveillance machine once the gears are turning?

This is a question I ask myself frequently, and I can't find the right path to get out of this vicious cycle.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by giardini on Friday April 10, 2015 @12:03PM (#9355192)
I would propose that

- all surveillance cease at some fixed moment and

- all information collected for a preceding fixed period (say 3 years', or maybe all of it) be made available for public inspection forever.

By "all" I mean just that - ALL information. Everything collected about everybody: presidents, prime ministers, senators & congressmen, corporations, churches, public and private institutions, trusts, public and private officials, their secretaries, clerks, bartenders and hired courtesans,etc - all of us would have our private information revealed.

This would cause an upheaval in the politics of the nation but would also provide a bonanza of invaluable information for society to review going forward. Do you want to know how corporate leaders break the law? Just look at the data and gather statistics. Are our politicians making illegal deals? Ditto. And of course, is my wife hiding something from me?

Allow prosecutions to proceed and the revealed information to be submitted as evidence. We might have to set up special courts and do triage to handle the influx of lawsuits and criminal arrests but we could at least get some of the rats out of the barn. Whether we burn the barn down or not is society's choice (doesn't seem we have a very good barn right now anyway - reminds me a bit of Animal House).

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by kbenson on Friday April 10, 2015 @12:37PM (#9355468)
The more I think about it, the more I come to the conclusion that privacy, as we currently know it, is a short lived phenomenon due to increased anonymity of large masses of people without the corresponding technology to accurately track information coming from them. The hundred person village of the past had little anonymity. The teeming metropoli of the future will have little as well. Privacy is information, and information moves towards more access, not less. As much as it pains me to admit it, there are parallels between privacy/surveillance and patents, copyrights and DRM, but the the roles are often reversed.

That not to say it's all bad, there are some possible upsides to a world with less privacy. For example, with the lack of any expectation of privacy for vast swaths of the average day, we may see a shift to people aligning their beliefs and actions, and that may be made easier by a shift in some of the less tolerant beliefs. This would by no means be a guaranteed, it would take work.

In the end though, I think whether privacy is somehow protected or not, one of the most important things we can do is make sure we are informed of, and inform the public of, what's likely and what's possible to have intercepted by surveillance. No matter the outcome, that's useful information for everyone to have, so they can act accordingly.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Terr_ on Friday April 10, 2015 @01:25PM (#9355788)
Long-term, the real issue isn't the overall level of privacy or exposure in the society, but the power-gap created by privacy-inequality.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Karunamon on Friday April 10, 2015 @01:45PM (#9355912)
So a post-privacy society is possible, then? Everybody having dirt on everyone else accomplishes a number of positive things.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Terr_ on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:25PM (#9356912)
And a number of negative ones. If someone could data-mine your "true opinions", group-think and mob-mentality becomes a much bigger issue.

Also, either extreme is primed for a big disruptive phase-change if some new technology comes along that makes it easier to conceal or uncover things.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by kbenson on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:53PM (#9357051)
I imagine a post-privacy society is one where people necessarily either are much more tolerant of disparate opinions, or clump together more to like-minded people in enclaves of homogeneity. Possibly a little of both.

To some degree, privacy is important because people judge bases on social norms. If that is lessened, so it the benefit of privacy (not necessarily to the same degree).

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Friday April 10, 2015 @03:19PM (#9356545)
Inequality is only a temporary phenomenon because information collection, storage, and processing is too expensive to be costless to the average person. That will not always be the case.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by imroot on Friday April 10, 2015 @02:35PM (#9356244)
What about in States where you have a right to Privacy?

(Alaska has an absolute right to privacy in their state constitution)

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by kbenson on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:00PM (#9357082)
IFF loss of privacy is taken as a given (a postulate of my original comment), then socially contructed laws can at best hope to stall the loss of privacy. Whether a law is written on the books about something is irrelevant if it's impossible to enforce.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Friday April 10, 2015 @03:19PM (#9356550)
Those rights will be taken about as seriously as the EU's "right to be forgotten".
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by olefoo on Friday April 10, 2015 @12:36PM (#9355460)
While this makes for a great piece of speculative fiction; I think you underestimate the violence that the powers that be are willing to deploy to defend the present arrangement.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by unabridged on Friday April 10, 2015 @03:10PM (#9356484)
I don't believe we can escape it. Surveillance technology becomes cheaper everyday, in the long term tiny automated drones with cameras will be cheaper than a steak from a real cow. Even if you limit the government's power, there will be private surveillance everywhere. Even if you stop companies in your country from making them, some other country will.

Our only hope is to better align our laws with our beliefs. Removing victimless crimes like drug laws will redirect this mass surveillance machine toward violent criminals. Full transparency in the government will prevent government officials from using the surveillance for personal gain or to harm political opponents.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by vijayr on Friday April 10, 2015 @11:27AM (#9354954)
I don't think it is possible. It is not just the gov, it is also private and public companies. Forget snooping for a second - let us just consider the public data. Once it is out there, who knows how many organizations have it? And even if we did, how are we going to force them to destroy it and not continue collecting more data? Most people give their data willingly either out of laziness or ignorance. If I have 15 different "store cards" in my wallet and let those stores happily track every single item I buy, willingly, who is to blame?
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by kbenson on Friday April 10, 2015 @11:59AM (#9355163)
If this is the natural progression of "information wants to be free", then it's probably worthwhile for us to figure out methods to live within this new reality. I'm not saying we shouldn't still fight it, but there should be a backup plan, in case it is futile.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by seanp2k2 on Friday April 10, 2015 @01:29PM (#9355810)
The backup plan is that we are not immortal, so however bad it gets, at least no one can force us to endure it forever.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by vijayr on Friday April 10, 2015 @07:50PM (#9357730)
Isn't "forever" in this case "as long as one lives"? But then, it is possible to tarnish somebody's name and legacy even after their death.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Friday April 10, 2015 @03:37PM (#9356638)
Most people give their data willingly because they get something worthwhile in exchange. The store cards exist because people trade tracking of their purchase data for discounted prices. Nobody is to blame because there is nothing to blame anyone for.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by vijayr on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:20PM (#9357836)
Nobody is to blame because there is nothing to blame anyone for.

Suppose I have a store card for a grocery store chain. If this grocery store sells my data to a health insurance company and the insurance company increases my premium based on my food purchasing habits, do you think it is fair? I am under the reasonable assumption that my purchase history is for the grocery chain only and in return for that data, I get some discounts on my purchases.

There was a case a while ago where a forum sold their users posts to a drug company. The forum members didn't expect that. Do you think it is fair?

In both examples above, the companies are most likely acting legally (After all, who reads 20 pages of legal crap before signing up for a forum) That doesn't mean it is the right thing to do.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:54AM (#9367569)
Insurers adjusting policies to accurately reflect risk is fantastic. They already do it now with haphazard accuracy - I get a partial rebate on any farm share or gym membership, and smoking cessation programs are on their dime completely.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Lawtonfogle on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:47PM (#9357019)
It is like a child giving me a shiny rock because they like the pie I made better. Am I not to blame because I understand the value of the diamond better than the child and use the information asymmetry to my advantage?
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:13PM (#9357397)
Your example only makes sense to you because you assume that the child could sell the diamond for enough money to buy the pie from you (or from someone else who has just as good of a pie) and have some left over. In the actual situation under discussion, there is no such option.

If that's not the case and you really would only part with the pie for that high of a price, and no other pie will do for the child, then what is there to complain about? How much do you think it costs to buy a pie made by, say, Gordon Ramsay? Feel free to replace with someone who is actually a good chef and not just a famous one if I made a poor choice.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Lawtonfogle on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:34AM (#9367473)
The example was to show someone taking advantage of information asymmetry. You are now just arguing the analogy. Do you believe it is acceptable to take advantage of information asymmetry when getting goods or services from someone (including children)?
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:47AM (#9367538)
I don't believe it is acceptable for there to be information asymmetry in the first place. Arguing about what to do when it's there is about as fruitful as arguing about how hard you should be allowed to beat your slaves.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by Lawtonfogle on Thursday April 16, 2015 @10:41AM (#9388219)
I don't see how one could prevent information asymmetry. With current technology, there is no way for a 10 year old to know all that a 30 year old knows.

To me it is like asking should we allow animals to kill each other. Not only can we not really stop it, even if we could it would kill any carnivores.

Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by LLWM on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:21PM (#9410241)
That's why 10 year olds are not allowed to enter into contracts with 30 year olds.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by api on Friday April 10, 2015 @11:57AM (#9355147)
Power is an end in itself. The war on drugs and the war on terror (and war in general) is a great way to expand it.
Re:DEA Orchestrates Disinformation Campaign to Conceal Surve... by e12e on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:46PM (#9357526)
It's kind of funny when you think about DDR and the Stasi; the other super-power ran the other into the ground, and now that power is performing mass surveillance in place of the Stasi...