Boggleheads have been asking that question for like 40 years. Vanguard funds (which simply pick the top 500 shares, or all the shares... depending on the fund...) outperform something like 85% of actively managed funds.
One theory is that modern markets are extremely efficient, which means that actively managed funds do not provide a benefit over just "trusting the market price" of various things.
I mean - if I was a trustee of a million fund let alone billion I would expect to know the baseline level of dumbest simplest possible investing process. That approach seem the simplest.
Because Vanguard's prices are the lowest. Where else are you going to go?
The typical fund charges between 1% to 2%. Vanguard charges 0.05% if you qualify for Admiral Shares ($10,000 minimum). Various ETFs can drop down to that amount, but you still have to deal with tracking error and commissions. $7 per trade typically... while Vanguard doesn't charge commissions if you own a Vanguard account and buy Vanguard Funds (or ETFs).
So ... What am I missing. Exchanges all use electronic trading now, Charles Schwann would give me 5 bucks per transaction.
Why does anyone pay percentages?
So my question to HN is - what is so hard (or not) about making market returns for a fund of this size?
I mean the obvious approach seems to buy 100m worth of shares in the top 1000 companies and just hold?
Perhaps it is worth not being fully invested all the time? Perhaps just making market is not worth it - but if it is, is the saving in fees compensating?