News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by ghaff on Thursday April 09, 2015 @05:01PM (#9351006)
What "special privilege" are you referring to in the example given? The special privilege to not have the property that they own sold out from under them against their wishes?
Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by LordKano on Thursday April 09, 2015 @05:15PM (#9351076)
Or the "special privilege" of using their land for the purpose for which it was acquired and had been used ever since?
Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by Kalium on Thursday April 09, 2015 @05:20PM (#9351101)
The special privilege of extra legal protection, such as a "right to farm".
Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by ghaff on Thursday April 09, 2015 @06:11PM (#9351393)
This is probably hopeless but all towns/cities dictate how properties in given areas can be used (i.e. zoning). They may change those rules but, for good reason, those rules are rarely retroactive. "Too bad about your house on one acre. We have five acre minimum zoning now. You'll have to tear it down--and good luck selling that property."

So there are restrictions on pretty much any use of property in a given town or state. The ability to build a house, run a farm, or build an asphalt plant is allowed or not allowed by the zoning. It's not about having a special "right to farm" any more or less than it's about having a special "right to build a house."

EDIT: Just add that the "right to farm" bylaws are mostly a reminder, especially to newcomers, that people have, um, a right to farm based on existing zoning. So don't move into our country town and then start a petition to close down the dairy farm down the street because it gets a bit smelly now and then during the summer.

Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by Kalium on Thursday April 09, 2015 @08:03PM (#9351813)
When you live a place, you can and should have a right to attempt to change it. This is a basic tenet of American government (taxation, representation, etc.). Just because a place has "always" been a given way does not and should not mean it can never be different.

That, I suppose, is a long way of saying that zoning can change. And sometimes other regulations change in ways that are inconvenient for some, especially when those people have failed to make a compelling case for why things should not change. We call this "democracy".

Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by LordKano on Thursday April 09, 2015 @11:42PM (#9352470)
Oh, it certainly can change. When the rightful owner of a property decides that it's time.

You have no legitimate right to demand that anyone do anything with their property based on your preference.

Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by Kalium on Friday April 10, 2015 @12:36AM (#9352613)
Only to the extent that details like democracy, zoning, and free speech permit.

Which is to say you can demand all you like, but until enough people agree with you the right way it doesn't matter.

Re:What the Deer Are Telling Us by LordKano on Friday April 10, 2015 @11:37AM (#9355028)
It's intellectually dishonest to cling to the principles of democracy on the municipal level but then complain about them at the state level.

"Right to farm" rules are an example of democracy in action.