Indeed. Yet even those people are making good incomes for horrible decisions. As the author said, even his kid's 529 outperforms this nonsense. Making money when the market is up (over the period under discussion) should be a given. That it's not means everyone involved should be fired.
Victim blaming. Well done.
Stupid people aren't victims; they're just stupid. The bankers had a responsibility to their shareholders to ask for the highest fees possible, and the managers of the $160 billion had a responsibility to say no. Looks like the bankers did their job.
So, let's play out the theories:
1) The pension managers WERE some of the most sophisticated investors on the planet.
So what the hell happened? You originally called them "irresponsible." Now you've edited to call them "stupid." What's your theory about what happened to these world-class investors? My point being, they can't simultaneously be in the "most sophisticated" class, and also in the "irresponsible" / "stupid" class.
Kickbacks? Got overly greedy and mis-fired? It could happen to literally anyone? Bad luck?
2) The pension managers WERE NOT some of the most sophisticated investors on the planet.
I agree with your assessment that they SHOULD HAVE BEEN. So what the hell happened? Did they lie when they were hired? Did they have a great track record (luck?), but flubbed this? Or did the person who hired them and put them in charge (the mayor?) trust someone they shouldn't have?
The real victims are the pensioners, and this story should be investigated. If not on their behalf, then as a lesson for other pensioners, pension managers, and the people who manage pension managers.
Unless your assertion is "even the most sophisticated investors can be idiotic."
I'd say "idiotic" should be upgraded to "colossally idiotic." $40M earnings on $160B in 10 years?
So, what do you think?
Not expecting an answer from you - I'm saying these become the questions I want answers to.
That is primarily why these numbers seems so ridiculous - the market had a few bad years, and then came back around. The people in charge of deploying this money should negotiate better terms, like paying fees only on net returns over longer periods of time (5 years instead of one year, for example). At the end of the day, it's their own fault for cutting lousy deals. $160 billion gives you a pretty big bargaining chip on fees.