Not quite. You have to be the diverse of the best (if I may mutilate English to make my point). Horror stories come out every year of the kid with perfect test scores and GPA who gets rejected from [insert prestigious school here]. It's not enough (and rightly so) to be the best of the best. You've got to have something different. Some distinguishing factors that come to mind are:
* Socio-economic background
* Athletic and musical ability
* Ethnicity and gender
* Unusual, proven talent in some rare area
I just fail to see how being an expert viola player or a state ping pong ball champ or a <gender,race combo> is going to help someone write superior software or conduct excellent science.
And I mean in a real, verifiable way, not some unconvincing, weak collection of anecdotes.
Of course, I'm not saying I can write super-superior software.
I think the trouble in this case would be the recruiting company that are reading them and only passing on the ones that tick all the right buzz word boxes ..