Re:Apple Watch Review: Bliss, but Only After a Steep Learnin...
by bkurtz13 on Wednesday April 08, 2015 @11:51AM
(#9341589)
I understand the reasoning behind curating a community to promote the kind of discourse users desire, but the type of self censorship that this comment promotes unsettles me.
I feel like the "negativity" that HN is so concerned about could be dealt with through down votes. The "gratuitous negativity" edict feels Orwellian, and I question its value vs unintended consequences.
Re:Apple Watch Review: Bliss, but Only After a Steep Learnin...
by gumby on Wednesday April 08, 2015 @01:05PM
(#9342223)
> Also, please consider the new Hacker News guideline against gratuitous negativity.
I'm glad for that guideline, but I didn't read the parent comment as gratuitous negativity, but as a legitimately posed criticism. That was my read.
As it happens I read the excerpted section differently when it was in context, but all that means is I disagreed with the parent's statement.
FWIW
If you look at the sentence in context, the preceding paragraph says it is the smartphone that "became the basis of a wide range of powerful new tech applications, from messaging to ride-sharing to payments." I think the author was trying to say that having the world respond to your "desires nearly automatically" might open similar "new tech vistas." That's how I read it anyway.
Also, please consider the new Hacker News guideline against gratuitous negativity.