Re:Apple Watch Review: Bliss, but Only After a Steep Learnin...
by danso on Wednesday April 08, 2015 @10:01AM
(#9340788)
Sorry, when you ask, "Why are you trashing a product review", are you suggesting that a product review is beyond critique? And if so, what is the purpose of your comment, except to critique a product-review-critiquing-comment?
To answer your question about using the Watch: no, I haven't. Which is why I haven't trashed the watch, but rather, trashing the OP -- who has used the Watch -- for coming up with gushing grandiose justification for the product rather than just talking about his experience with the product. It's as if he wants us to overlook the problem (as detailed in his own review) that the Watch itself may not be a revolution...but just wait and see
I'm all for speculating on the bigger picture, including inside a product review. But this speculation is just trash, which is why I'm critiquing it. He throws around the word "bionic" as if it didn't mean anything, and then he tries to dress up the activities of opening a hotel room or calling an Uber as tasks that will be profoundly changed by the paradigm of the Watch.
To answer your question about using the Watch: no, I haven't. Which is why I haven't trashed the watch, but rather, trashing the OP -- who has used the Watch -- for coming up with gushing grandiose justification for the product rather than just talking about his experience with the product. It's as if he wants us to overlook the problem (as detailed in his own review) that the Watch itself may not be a revolution...but just wait and see
I'm all for speculating on the bigger picture, including inside a product review. But this speculation is just trash, which is why I'm critiquing it. He throws around the word "bionic" as if it didn't mean anything, and then he tries to dress up the activities of opening a hotel room or calling an Uber as tasks that will be profoundly changed by the paradigm of the Watch.