If the system isn't working you probably won't live very long. And while there may be certain functional alleles that may increase odds of an initial false positive stimulation, by in large the entire class of failure known as "allergic reactions" is simply a result of how the system itself works. You don't really need to invoke genetic differences to see how it fails. This is why the hygiene hypothesis is so strong.
There are actually four major categories of hypersensitivity that involve different cell populations and signalling pathways (eg. why poison ivy allergy is different from pine allergy).
If you're interested, the Wikipedia articles aren't a bad read. I also recommend Janeway's Immunobiology as a great intro to the entire subject.
I mean, you might piss it off if you sneeze on it, I guess. Yay?
Not that I necessarily believe that's a good explanation for allergies, but it's plausible enough to think about.
I think peanuts as a crop have suffered from very intensive industrialization more than other crops. Also, I have read that the storage facilities have problems with mold growth. Many peanut butters test positive for mold toxins.
With many of these food allergies where people wonder why it seems to be a modern phenomenon can probably be linked to the degradation of the industrialized food supply.
Furthermore, the ongoing stress of slightly toxin loaded food primes the immune system to over-reactivatity. Things like pollen allergies are aggravated.
Well of course. I'm just a layman when it comes to allergies, but I thought it was well understood that allergies were the body's inflammatory reaction to an allergen, i.e., an attempt to eliminate (or otherwise neutralize) the allergen. The problem is that, according to the conventional wisdom, the body's reaction to allergen is mistaken. Presumably the body is attempting to target and eliminate something that is actually harmful, but it winds up responding to something harmless, or by triggering a response so severe that it does more harm than good. That's, broadly speaking, the difference between an allergen and a pathogen/poison. A poison/pathogen will actually harm you if it is not eliminated. An allergen will not (or, at least, not in proportion to the severity of the reaction. But I don't see why the observation above has anything to say about the real question, which is why does the body sometimes mistakes one for the other, and freaks out in the presence of harmless substances?