Re:The Surface 3 can charge itself
by ihuman on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @10:17AM
(#9334166)
I'm assuming you are still losing power. Some power is taken out via the USB and put back into the computer, and some is use to power the device like normal. Since the power put back into the computer is not larger than the power being taken out, there is still a net loss in power over time.
Re:The Surface 3 can charge itself
by rikkus on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @10:24AM
(#9334228)
The problem is not to do with the 'power put back' being 'larger', it's to do with efficiency. If charging and discharging a battery were 100% efficient and there were no losses to heat through the rest of the system, then there'd be no discharging, but, yes, due to the laws of the universe, this will always cause a net loss.
Re:The Surface 3 can charge itself
by klaustopher on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @10:24AM
(#9334235)
I still bet this is the reason that Apple didn't put a second USB-C port on the new MacBook. It would create a perpetuum mobile and Homer Simpson would not approve since "In this house we follow the rules of thermodynamics!"
Not only is there power drain, but the device will think it's plugged in and actively disable power-saving features (someone correct me if I'm wrong).