News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by bonsaitree on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @01:26PM (#933601)
Aside from being sourced directly from the Rackspace blog, there are NO logical/technical reasons given for the the switch.

This is a pure PR puff piece.

Why is this even on HN in the first place?!

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by mark_l_watson on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @12:04PM (#933409)
I haven't yet used Rackspace cloud services, but from reading the documentation, I do like that they integrate a persistent file system with compute units (whatever they call them). Compare with EC2 and separate EBS volumes:

I used to spend a lot of time with EC2 deployments dealing with attaching EBS volumes, then starting services that required the EBS volumes (though I finally got this down pat).

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by jacquesm on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @10:58AM (#933260)
It would be nice to see their rationale for using cloud services at all, their use case seems to be much better served by leasing a bunch of servers.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by easp on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @01:31PM (#933613)
Why would their use case seem better suited to renting a bunch of servers?

The 400% jump in video utilization upon the release of the iPhone 3gs probably represented a major inflection in their rate of storage growth, and their peak need for media processing capability. That may have been something they could have anticipated, but it would have been easy to end up dramatically over- or under-provisioned.

In addition, I'd expect that their load varies a lot. Some of it may be predictable, but short lived (like increased photo and videoposting around the holidays), so renting 2x as many servers for a week a few times a year seems like a hassle. Other spikes are going to be unpredictable and of unknown duration. Keeping too much extra capacity around for these situations can quickly eat up the savings from renting servers.

At the very least, "cloud computing" is going to be valuable for handling large peaks, even if they have some more permenant infrastructure in place. Look at electrical power generation. Utilities invest heavily in steam plants to achieve high efficincies andclow costs for meeting their base load. To meet peak demand, they fire up less efficient gas turbines. The higher operating cost is more than offset by the fact that they are so much cheaper to build and can be spun up and down quickly.

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by PStamatiou on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @12:17PM (#933435)
Also - I wonder if there were any incentives. From past experience I know that such companies will give huge discounts and sometimes free service to bring such brands on board.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by psranga on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @12:33PM (#933477)
Yep, not news unless they have the exact same contract that I will if I sign up.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by milestinsley on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @11:54AM (#933385)
Their choice to use cloud services makes perfect sense. It will enable them to create new servers on the fly, when required, as well as resizing and allocating resources as needed, keeping costs down and efficiency high.

It inspires me that we have these cloud services at our disposal. And maybe Posterous (and many other great startups) would not have been conceived without the founders having access to such technology.

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by jacquesm on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @12:07PM (#933418)
It's the 'keeping costs down' bit that I have a problem with, I have to date not found any evidence that that is the case.

Whether you lease or buy your servers, if you have a > 30% 'on' pattern and use anything but trivial bandwidth then using a cloud instead is very expensive.

Sure you can instantly call up more instances, but there are only a limited number of cases for which that is true, and almost none of them involve web based services (which are pretty much 'on' all the time, with some fluctuations because of the day/night shift).

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by psranga on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @12:39PM (#933497)
Avoiding upfront costs helps lengthening the startup's runway, even if total cost until time=infinity is higher.

Building fault-tolerance (like S3/EBS do) is a HARD problem. That's worth paying for.

Once you move your data to the cloud for reliability, you almost have to move the processing close to the data to get acceptable performance.

Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by siculars on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @10:57AM (#933253)
it sounds like they used to use aws, specifically s3. why did they switch? performance? cost?
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by Pahalial on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @11:55AM (#933389)
Yeah, the direct comparison in the title and opening paragraph seems to be pure SEO, as the reasoning behind Rackspace > AWS is never elaborated on at all.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by patio11 on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @01:19PM (#933588)
This may be surprising to the Internet generation, but companies have crowed when they win accounts over from more established competitors for even longer than there has been search engines. Among less worthy chest thumping reasons, providing social proof helps motivate customers who are on the fence by letting your internal champions say "Hey, X just switched to Z, we look to X for leadership in our industry, let's do Z" and "Z is a safe choice, after all, X uses it. I can recommend Z to my boss and not get fired".
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by aristus on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @11:19AM (#933301)
Awesome. Now let's work towards the day when this is not an exclusive choice.
Re:Posterous chooses The Rackspace Cloud over Amazon by jamesbritt on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @10:57AM (#933251)
As has todoist.com.