There's extremely vile behavior in these circles, a sort of one-up-manship that ends up creating environments where things like Gamergate can prosper.
ethics in video game journalism.
So perhaps the 'objects of worship' are in some sense for the worshippers no longer just a piece of art or entertainment, and so cannot be held criticically by them without creating a certain amount of cognitive dissonance.
To me (and I imagine many/most adults) rehashing and revisiting a film (e.g such as star wars) and its contents diminishes the film, regardless of how great the film is. There is clearly a different mode that some people enter into whereby it becomes something else, a touchstone for the communal experience, and a piece scripture for their worship. It takes all sorts!
I hate a bunch of nerd sacred cows and I criticize them all the time. People are surprised for a second and pantomime outrage and then everything goes back to normal. The trick is to signal personal preference, not signal out-group contempt, which is kind of a trigger for some people.
This really is the main problem with nerd/geek/gamer/etc "culture", it's actually very exclusionary to people and if you don't possess the right amount of shared knowledge, you're ostracized. Nerd "culture" is also uncritical of the objects of worship, watch what happens if someone criticizes a sacred cow like Firefly or Game of Thrones.
Critical of individuals and uncritical of art is exactly the opposite of what we should strive to be.