Re:Raven paradox
by hurin on Saturday April 04, 2015 @08:30PM
(#9322689)
To be clear:
>Nevermore, my pet raven, is black.
Is not evidence (This is because you don't know anything about the Distribution from which Nevermore is a sample):
>supporting the hypothesis that all ravens are black.
It is evidence saying: there exists at least one Raven and that Raven is Black.
and
>My Apple is Green
Is evidence that there exists at least one thing which is not Black and Not a Raven. That does not tell you anything about the existence of Raven's or Black things in the world.
Is not evidence (This is because you don't know anything about the Distribution from which Nevermore is a sample):
>supporting the hypothesis that all ravens are black.
It is evidence saying: there exists at least one Raven and that Raven is Black.
and >My Apple is Green
Is evidence that there exists at least one thing which is not Black and Not a Raven. That does not tell you anything about the existence of Raven's or Black things in the world.