Then you might ask, why do we care about how formal reasoning works? Because the alternative, common-sense reasoning, works really well up to a point, after which it fails badly.
I must admit, while I was mildly interested by it, it did strike me as the kind of "philosophising" that your regular bloke down the pub would find rather baffling - "I know ravens are black. You know ravens are black. Why are we even discussing this?"
How often do we hear variations on the Black Swan fallacy, and how often do people fall for it,and repeat it in discussions?
Your regular bloke down the pub finds Schroedinger and chaos theory rather pointless as well (And to be honest "Just make the damn box out of perspex" is a fairly sensible response to Schroedinger.), but that does not make the study of theoretical concepts and logic pointless.
For example, I am fascinated by the philosophy of science, how people got to thinking something, and what was going on around them that influenced them. I am also fascinated by the anthropology surrounding the formation of religion. Both relatively pointless, but ultimately understanding why we think something helps move us forward.
PS: I still think "If a tree falls...." is very baffling ;)
Can someone explain what we gain by studying this question? It seems vastly pointless to me. No one would seriously attempt to learn anything by finding evidence for the contrapositive this way; if no one is doing it, why should we study the oddness of this manner of inquiry?